Hogg is a dud Test spinner

[Dry Rot]

Lousy performance when it counted at the SCG - made Clarke look good.

Ponting must be praying that Killer MacGill will be fit soon.

[GVGjr]

Lousy performance when it counted at the SCG - made Clarke look good.

Ponting must be praying that Killer MacGill will be fit soon.

It will be very tempting to play four quicks for the next test. Hogg was brilliant with the bat in the first dig but struggled with the ball.

[hujsh]

I always thought that the last day on the SCG would be where we could see if he can play and he has done soooooooooo bad. Possibly worst performance by a front line spinner at the SCG ever.

[Sockeye Salmon]

I always thought that the last day on the SCG would be where we could see if he can play and he has done soooooooooo bad. Possibly worst performance by a front line spinner at the SCG ever.

What about:

SCG MacGill 38-5-146-0
v India 2003/04

[Mantis]

What about:

SCG MacGill 38-5-146-0
v India 2003/04


Or perhaps:

SK Warne 45-7-150-1
v India 1991/2

[Sunshine]

Or perhaps:

SK Warne 45-7-150-1
v India 1991/2

Was that the Shastri 200 innings? He gave SKW are pasting that day.

[hujsh]

Or perhaps:

SK Warne 45-7-150-1
v India 1991/2

Originally Posted by Sockeye Salmon
What about:

SCG MacGill 38-5-146-0
v India 2003/04


Ok, were they first or second innings or Match. (bit hard on young Warney)

Also, the teams made high scores then. In this match the part timers caused more problems then Hogg.

[GVGjr]

With the potential Pakistan tour in mind, Hogg would need to have a good match in Adelaide wouldn't he or would we just look at MacGill?

[hujsh]

With the potential Pakistan tour in mind, Hogg would need to have a good match in Adelaide wouldn't he or would we just look at MacGill?

McGain is now my choice which is big since i didn't want him to play for Victoria originally.