Swans out to collar Dogs young gun Mitch Wallis

[LostDoggy]

OK, let's just forgive and forget eh?

[bornadog]

OK, let's just forgive and forget eh?

Of course

[1eyedog]

I can, considering they were having a go at an 18 year old.

You mean like you were at Smith the other week with his one kick in 12 minutes

[Mofra]

You mean like you were at Smith the other week with his one kick in 12 minutes

I don't recall BAD saying that he won't make it as a footballer because of it

There's a difference in saying a kid has had a bad game (and Wally had some bad ones last year, pointed out fairly by Woof posters) and that an 18 year old who carved it up as a junior won't make it as a footballer.

I dare say anyone who wrote him off last year is happy with his 2012 form so the point may be moot anyway.

[bornadog]

You mean like you were at Smith the other week with his one kick in 12 minutes

I don't recall BAD saying that he won't make it as a footballer because of it

There's a difference in saying a kid has had a bad game (and Wally had some bad ones last year, pointed out fairly by Woof posters) and that an 18 year old who carved it up as a junior won't make it as a footballer.

I dare say anyone who wrote him off last year is happy with his 2012 form so the point may be moot anyway.

I believe Mofra has answered for me.

You really didn't like my comment on his one disposal and 4 tackles. Surely one can make a comment on a game

FYI, I like Smith he has guts and determination and I believe he will make it.

I will never ever bag a young kid on our list (or any list) and have stuck up for many over the years. Sometimes I was wrong, like I thought Stack might make it, but I believe in giving them a go before severe criticism is made.

[Desipura]

I believe Mofra has answered for me.

You really didn't like my comment on his one disposal and 4 tackles. Surely one can make a comment on a game

FYI, I like Smith he has guts and determination and I believe he will make it.

I will never ever bag a young kid on our list (or any list) and have stuck up for many over the years. Sometimes I was wrong, like I thought Stack might make it, but I believe in giving them a go before severe criticism is made.

And you thought picking up Barry Hall was a bad mistake.

[bornadog]

And you thought picking up Barry Hall was a bad mistake.

Yes true, don't like recruiting 30 year olds.

[LostDoggy]

Yes true, don't like recruiting 30 year olds.

That should read 31 year olds. 30 year olds are still young mate…

[bornadog]

That should read 31 year olds. 30 year olds are still young mate…

Are you