Jason McCartney

[Sedat]

Clayton is a dud

He's a dud recruiter.

[KT31]

Clayton is a dud

IMO huge understatement.

[Remi Moses]

Good dealer in trade time , but not a great recruiter .

[GVGjr]

Good dealer in trade time , but not a great recruiter .

Which ones stand out?

[Remi Moses]

Did well out of the Hudson trade . Thought we did exceptionally well for McMahon

[bulldogtragic]

I wouldn't touch Clayton if JMac leaves. However, Rocket has been a successful coach at Sydney & Dogs, and has tried to turn around GCS from a dire position. He was a footy boss at Collingwood in between. As far as a senior, experienced footy industry professional goes, he's got 25 years of experience at looking at lists from the inside at 4 clubs in different roles. He could also be a sounding board for others at the club, including coaches. Hopefully JMac signs on, but with Mrs Eade's business in Melbourne you'd think Rocket is coming back and will be looking for a job. Could he do the job well?

[hujsh]

I wouldn't touch Clayton if JMac leaves. However, Rocket has been a successful coach at Sydney & Dogs, and has tried to turn around GCS from a dire position. He was a footy boss at Collingwood in between. As far as a senior, experienced footy industry professional goes, he's got 25 years of experience at looking at lists from the inside at 4 clubs in different roles. He could also be a sounding board for others at the club, including coaches. Hopefully JMac signs on, but with Mrs Eade's business in Melbourne you'd think Rocket is coming back and will be looking for a job. Could he do the job well?

Did we ever find a new 'bad cop' once Monty left?

[bornadog]

I wouldn't touch Clayton if JMac leaves. However, Rocket has been a successful coach at Sydney & Dogs, and has tried to turn around GCS from a dire position. He was a footy boss at Collingwood in between. As far as a senior, experienced footy industry professional goes, he's got 25 years of experience at looking at lists from the inside at 4 clubs in different roles. He could also be a sounding board for others at the club, including coaches. Hopefully JMac signs on, but with Mrs Eade's business in Melbourne you'd think Rocket is coming back and will be looking for a job. Could he do the job well?

I can't see Eade being a List Manager. I doubt he has the skills to do this type of job. Eade is a professional coach, but sadly his time is up. Whether he can be a mentor to a young coach I don't now, but that would suit him better.

[Twodogs]

Did we ever find a new 'bad cop' once Monty left?

Or a decent sounding board for the coaches' tactics and idea. An experienced head to talk them through with. It's a young group and there's been some interesting experiments this year.