List Management 2015

[Bulldog Joe]

Dixon would certainly fit our structure nicely. Between him, Roughy and Boyd, we'd be able to match up against most ruck line ups and certainly wouldn't lose anything around the ground.

Dixon is the one I would like.

[Axe Man]

Dixon seems to have some potential attitude/behavioral issues (but then so do half the Suns list apparently).

Supposedly came back from the off season overweight and also possibly broke the booze ban that 3 of his teammates have been suspended for.

Perhaps a change of scenery might straighten out some of these Gold Coast wannabee rockstars.

[1eyedog]

What would we have to give up to get the Suns to play ball with us?

[boydogs]

What would we have to give up to get the Suns to play ball with us?

To Eade & Clayton, Justin Sherman maybe?

[Axe Man]

What would we have to give up to get the Suns to play ball with us?

Jarrad Grant - Clayton may see the chance to turn him around and avoid that swim he promised!

[Greystache]

To Eade & Clayton, Justin Sherman maybe?

Or at least just a skinny outside player with a nice kick who can play off half back and won't defend.

[Twodogs]

Or at least just a skinny outside player with a nice kick who can play off half back and won't defend.

Sounds a bit like me.

[Mantis]

Or at least just a skinny outside player with a nice kick who can play off half back and won't defend.

Where is Jordan McMahon these days?

[Bulldog Joe]

Or at least just a skinny outside player with a nice kick who can play off half back and won't defend.

So we should have kept Everitt to package with Higgins and J Grant just for this trade.

[Greystache]

Where is Jordan McMahon these days?

I think there's a number of people and organisations asking this question.

[Greystache]

So we should have kept Everitt to package with Higgins and J Grant just for this trade.

Or trade them to Richmond for a first round draft pick.

[Sedat]

Actually Dalrymple is almost the bipolar opposite of Scott Clayton - screwed up his first effort but has barely put a foot wrong since, whereas Clayton absolutely nailed his first draft and pretty much screwed most others up thereafter.

[bornadog]

Actually Dalrymple is almost the bipolar opposite of Scott Clayton - screwed up his first effort but has barely put a foot wrong since, whereas Clayton absolutely nailed his first draft and pretty much screwed most others up thereafter.

So guys like Brownlow medallist, All Australians were a miss.??? Really.

We go over this time and time again on this forum, but we won't all agree. Yes plenty of misses but also plenty of top footballers in his time with us.

Dalrmple hasn't got everything right to date, but that is the nature of recruiting. I really question Pearce, Lower, Goodes, Fuller, Young, Prudden,(could still work) Schofield, Skinner, Moles, Hooper, Austin, Markovic, and Mulligan.

Excellent pickups in the last few years, but helps when you have picks 4, 5 or 6 and those years would have been hard to miss a good player. Yes I know Walsh didn't make it and he was a top 4/ 5. So what, so was Howard.

[Mofra]

Excellent pickups in the last few years, but helps when you have picks 4, 5 or 6 and those years would have been hard to miss a good player. Yes I know Walsh didn't make it and he was a top 4/ 5. So what, so was Howard.

Howard was a pick in the teens, made before Dalrymple was a full time recruiter (he was working part time that year!)

Not impossible to miss a good player considering I'd argue that Macrae & Stringer are outperforming picks taken before them and Bonti at pick 4 was seen as a reach but he's so far the best of his class.
Dahl & Jong as rookie picks are a big tick IMO and we've already got a kid from last year playing senior football.

I'm pretty happy with Dalrymple's efforts since coming on board full time.

[bornadog]

Howard was a pick in the teens, made before Dalrymple was a full time recruiter (he was working part time that year!)

Not impossible to miss a good player considering I'd argue that Macrae & Stringer are outperforming picks taken before them and Bonti at pick 4 was seen as a reach but he's so far the best of his class.
Dahl & Jong as rookie picks are a big tick IMO and we've already got a kid from last year playing senior football.

I'm pretty happy with Dalrymple's efforts since coming on board full time.

I am too, I don't like broad statements that after the 1999 draft, Clayton screwed up.