MRP - General thread

[bornadog]

How does Jack Ziebell get cleared for contact on Sam Mitchell.

see hit here

I refer everything back to the Jong incident which was assessed as 3 matches, an 1 match discount for early plea.

[bulldogtragic]

Good bloke reduction and fear that Brayshaw & Scott will scream blue murder that JZ is being singled out with regard to high contact.

[bornadog]

Jong actually turns and doesn't hit the head, his arse hits his shoulder, head is around back of Jong.

[bornadog]

Compare here

[Twodogs]

Can't get that second image to show BAD. The Ziebell one.

[bulldogtragic]

It's simple really. They kept rubbing Zieball out and he walk out of the tribunal and say 'I'm not changing the way I play'. So they had to keep suspending him or not.

[LostDoggy]

One bloke got knocked out and was out for the rest of the match, the other got straight back up. There's the difference.

[Remi Moses]

How in hell did Vince not get suspended ?
Chooklotto

[SonofScray]

One bloke got knocked out and was out for the rest of the match, the other got straight back up. There's the difference.

Why does one deserve punishment and not the other?

[bornadog]

Compare here

Can't get that second image to show BAD. The Ziebell one.

Sorry just realized and fixed

[LostDoggy]

Why does one deserve punishment and not the other?

Not saying I agree with it, but that's how the MRP role and have done so for many years now. I'm not sure why people are still suprised..

[Bulldog Joe]

Unfortunately they decide based on outcome and not intent.

[LostDoggy]

Unfortunately they decide based on outcome and not intent.

How ridiculous that a judiciary system working for the AFL would opperate in this manner.
Imagine the uproar if our judicial system worked the same way.
"Your honor my client yes did have the intent to murder his wife in their bedroom but because the outcome was both unsatisfactory and underwhelming for my client,
I can see no other option for you my lud and the good people of this jury to acquit my client on all charges of intent to kill her because she is physically still in our presence as we can all plainly see for ourselves,like our very noses on our faces,
Your Lordship."

[bulldogtragic]

There's a clip of Dangerfield kneeing an opponent on the ground tonight. The good bloke rule to downgrade it to nothing or a fine to be applied this week by the MRP me feels.

[ledge]

There's a clip of Dangerfield kneeing an opponent on the ground tonight. The good bloke rule to downgrade it to nothing or a fine to be applied this week by the MRP me feels.

Seriously ? Nothing in that at all he was just pulling his leg out and running off.
The media jump on the tiniest things to dramatise and write something.
I think the MRP should fine the media for stupidity.