Jack Redpath

[bornadog]

Striking Phil Davis?

Doing the lord's work IMO.

Wasn't even a strike, a slap on the face - 3 weeks for that, and can accept 2

[AndrewP6]

Not sure how we would get Kelly if he doesn't go to North.

Personally i'd never give Stringer up. He's still young and has had to go through a lot personally
the last couple of years. He's an integral part of the team and if you start trading those types away then you
are really left with no soul. We won the premiership last year largely because of the group as a whole's ability to
galvanise together. We all talked about the "we all love each other" factor, well there are certain people you just can't trade out
for more than football reasons and I think Jake is one of those.
Besides we have so few players with X factor about them, and with these guys you just have to take the good with the bad sometimes.

Agree 100%

[bulldogtragic]

Has he played his last game with us?

[lemmon]

He's clearly not that bright after just returning from a jumper punch charge. Can't really blame anyone for not getting an extended run.

[bulldogtragic]

He's clearly not that bright after just returning from a jumper punch charge. Can't really blame anyone for not getting an extended run.

He's like a less talented Jarrad Waite. If it's not injury, it's a mindless suspension that breaks the games continuity.

[bornadog]

He's clearly not that bright after just returning from a jumper punch charge. Can't really blame anyone for not getting an extended run.

Have you actually seen the incident? You will change your mind if you did.

[Ozza]

At worst, Red's was a forceful push to the side of the neck.

The jumper punch I'll wear that that one was a stupid act.

The 'knee' into the Melbourne player last year was absolute nonsense and just inadvertently happened in a wrestle.

[GVGjr]

Heard a decent rumour that Norf are into Stringer in a very big way.......

Would mean keeping Red for sure.

And so they should. I'm not sure of the Redders and Stringer comparison though. Stringer leaving might be better news for Crameri.

[Flamethrower]

Striking Phil Davis?

Doing the lord's work IMO.

Davis must have a sharp tongue on the field....plenty of forwards have been fined or suspended punching him clearly in retaliation to something.

[ratsmac]

Lance Franklin got off the exact same thing against Hodge a couple weeks ago. Red tried to push his shoulder as Davis pushes Red and his hands slip high. MRP are a joke. Red would of been better of kicking Davis in the face.

I really hope we challenge this shite just for the sake of justice.

From now on our players aren't allowed to touch oppostion players unless its with our face on their foot.

[always right]

According to the AFL website he was done for "low impact to the head". I assume the reference to the head rather than the neck, has contributed to the penalty. Would the situation change if the club challenged on the basis that contact was made to Davis's neck and not his head?

[MrMahatma]

I'd question keeping him on the list. The suspension is a joke though.

[merantau]

I would keep Redpath. He will return our faith in him with a big Finals Series if we make it and a huge 2018!

[Happy Days]

Davis must have a sharp tongue on the field....plenty of forwards have been fined or suspended punching him clearly in retaliation to something.

Or maybe he's just a diving wanker?

[Bulldog Joe]

The club absolutely needs to challenge this one.

We continually roll over to rubbish MRP assessments and it just must stop.