Who would you have JMac target this year?

[kruder]

He is currently on $600,000 a year.

Yeah I know and is not getting a game. Its ridiculous to pay 600k for a player who may not be in your best 22 there is obviously serious question marks against him.

[GVGjr]

Yeah I know and is not getting a game. Its ridiculous to pay 600k for a player who may not be in your best 22 there is obviously serious question marks against him.

In today's environment you pay significantly more for players without question marks

[Rocket Science]

Speaking of question marks ...

In an alternate universe might the club entertain a pitch for Paddy McCartin?

I know. I know! But thinking out loud.

- We have an obvious need for talented natural forwards who can take a contested mark.
- His age fits our core.
- St.Kilda may be nearing wits end with him, with sapping patience and an eye on dwindling future returns. If they could flip him for something of value to them, would they listen?
- Some on our end might surmise he couldn't possibly endure more of the same wretched run he's had, surely. A new environment that diffuses the pressure of his draft position and swelling sense of disappointment might be good for him.

It'd be a breathtaking gamble of course. One I think carries far more risk than is sensible for any suitor. But would the club? And what would we be prepared to pay in return?

[azabob]

My biggest concern with McCartin is his head knocks and ability to stay on the park.

[Rocket Science]

My biggest concern with McCartin is his head knocks and ability to stay on the park.

No question, I'd be highly leery as well. But if the bulk of his bad luck's behind him and he can be grabbed at a reduced rate for a 1st overall pick, the potential rewards might be pretty attractive for a club like ours.

[bornadog]

No question, I'd be highly leery as well. But if the bulk of his bad luck's behind him and he can be grabbed at a reduced rate for a 1st overall pick, the potential rewards might be pretty attractive for a club like ours.

Could he be switched to a CHB role?

[Twodogs]

My biggest concern with McCartin is his head knocks and ability to stay on the park.

The head knocks are a big concern and I'm also concerned about his diabetes. I can't think of too many really great players who also suffered from diabetes, Dale Weightman being the only example I can think of although I'm sure there are others.

My point being diabetes is a chronic disease that can cause all sorts of allied health problems. And although we have made breakthroughs in testing and treatment and administration of insulin I'd still be wary.

PS, I don't mean to upset or demean anyone suffering from diabetes. It's a terrible illness that is rife through my own family.

[Rocket Science]

Could he be switched to a CHB role?

That sounds just like something Bevo would do with a dedicated forward.

Interesting question. Perhaps, if he could build more aerobic capacity, but with his sticky hands, leading ability and forward craft I'd be loath to recruit a type we're crying out for only to chuck him down the other end of the park.

[bulldogtragic]

The head knocks are a big concern and I'm also concerned about his diabetes. I can't think of too many really great players who also suffered from diabetes, Dale Weightman being the only example I can think of although I'm sure there are others.

My point being diabetes is a chronic disease that can cause all sorts of allied health problems. And although we have made breakthroughs in testing and treatment and administration of insulin I'd still be wary.

PS, I don't mean to upset or demean anyone suffering from diabetes. It's a terrible illness that is rife through my own family.

A health professional of mine had a son play all his juniors with Paddy was best friends with Paddy's parents. Now obviously she could not disclosure sensitive info, suffice to say his Diabetes is not even a remote concern for Paddy and playing football at any level. It's believed the it was started as a bad rumour at draft time to get him to slide past the first selection. But it didn't work.

With Riewoldt gone, surely he backs himself in to take that spot surely?

[ledge]

A health professional of mine had a son play all his juniors with Paddy was best friends with Paddy's parents. Now obviously she could not disclosure sensitive info, suffice to say his Diabetes is not even a remote concern for Paddy and playing football at any level. It's believed the it was started as a bad rumour at draft time to get him to slide past the first selection. But it didn't work.

With Riewoldt gone, surely he backs himself in to take that spot surely?

Sounds like he is extremely lazy then. Apart from the head knocks.

[Avoid the rush]

Can't believe I am saying this let alone writing it but ........I have a real liking for big Cox! Yes that's right I reckon Mason Cox would be a great get for our club. (NO I did not mispell it) Imagine getting first use of the ball in the middle. Ah yes halcyon days indeed. Wynd Dempsey etc. (MEMORIES) Roughie could float around on big blokes, Toyd could play in the FORWARD line and when Cox was resting forward, imagine Tory Zarsoff, Bonty, Del, String at the drop. He has such a big upside as well and since 3rd man up was removed we have lacked badly in this department. Amongst my colleauges I am a man alone, but what do you guys think????

[GVGjr]

Can't believe I am saying this let alone writing it but ........I have a real liking for big Cox! Yes that's right I reckon Mason Cox would be a great get for our club. (NO I did not mispell it) Imagine getting first use of the ball in the middle. Ah yes halcyon days indeed. Wynd Dempsey etc. (MEMORIES) Roughie could float around on big blokes, Toyd could play in the FORWARD line and when Cox was resting forward, imagine Tory Zarsoff, Bonty, Del, String at the drop. He has such a big upside as well and since 3rd man up was removed we have lacked badly in this department. Amongst my colleauges I am a man alone, but what do you guys think????

I think he might be someone we have an interest in. He's a bit better up forward than most ruckman but won't get the time he needs as a ruckman behind Grundy. He could possible form a decent combination with Boyd.

I'd need a little bit of convincing but it has some merit if we can't get Martin.

[Topdog]

If Cox was Australian no one would know who he is. Rubbish.

[always right]

Cox has just about the worst hands in the VFL.

[Remi Moses]

Cox is shocking when the ball hits the ground as well .