Originally Posted by
Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
hujsh in a post on the "Adam Cooney is he lazy?" thread got me thinking about the following.
He basically said that if the draft position of Adam Cooney was a secret, most would be happy with his output to date.
This got me thinking about whether as supporters we distort our view of players and their relative performance based on where they were drafted.
If say for want of an example- Adam Cooney was a 2nd rounder or later would be be focussing on his positive attributes ,more so than his relative weaknesses, and in turn hailing his pickup as a bargain and therefore based on his cost we would judge his career to date to be an overwhelming success.
On the flip side would we judge someone like Dale Morris who came to the club as a mature rookie, differently if he was actually a 1st rounder. If he was a 1st rounder would we be lamenting that we should've picked a guy with better disposal skills, and more natual footballing talent with that pick. And therefore would we rate him as highly as the majority of us do?
As a result of Adam being taken at number one (through no fault of his own) are we therefore expecting him, and others to be the be all and end all of footy players, and thefore judging his and others performance through this prism? Is this fair?
Draft picks are obviously important to the future of any clubs playing list, as this is where (one way or another) all clubs get their players from. It is though, given the young age of most draftees, a bit of a crap shoot as we are by and large picking someone who is still for all intents and purposes still a physcially developing teenager. Meaning that there is a fair amount of uncertainty as to how that young adult will develop into their adult frame and mind.
By the way I was just using Cooney and Morris as examples and am not intending either way to over/underrate their value or question their relative worth to the club. Merely I wanted to use them as an analogy to make my point more clear on high low picks players so as to get peoples thoughts on the question, as they represent the extremes of the draft scale, with cooney being pick one and Morris beig a mature rookie lister.
Perception is an interesting thing that humans employ to make a range of opinions on many things, and like the old saying " Don't believe all that you see" it isn't necessarily the most accurate of ways for humans to make overall assessments.
But as many marketers, PR people and advertisers will tell you it is of vital importance as an overall influencer of decision.