Rob Murphy - Torn Patella tendon

[bornadog]

There is no way any club would trade draft picks this year (or any year) for that matter for Kosi, a pick after 80 being the exception.

You get more hardness and consistency in a tub of yoghurt, than you get from Kosi.

Simply put, Kosi is a dud, but a dud that could fill a void and be a back-up ruckman for Jolly in Sydney. He is not capable of holding down a KFP.

St Kilda are screaming out for pacy ball carriers in the mould of Farren Ray. If Hall wanted to leave Sydney, and I'm sure the swans will not stand in his way, he could help develop Grant and Boumann during a 2 year stint with us.

I would still prefer Kosi over Hall. Hall has done nothing over the poast two years, kicking 41 goals from 15 this year, 44 goals from 20 games last year. Hardly a brilliant record. He had a couple of good years in 2004 - 6.

[Dry Rot]

I would still prefer Kosi over Hall. Hall has done nothing over the poast two years, kicking 41 goals from 15 this year, 44 goals from 20 games last year. Hardly a brilliant record. He had a couple of good years in 2004 - 6.

To be fair the Swans weren't too flash over the past 2 seasons.

[bornadog]

To be fair the Swans weren't too flash over the past 2 seasons.

Still made the finals and now Hall is about to turn 32 years old.