-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Originally Posted by
Ozza
Of course we have been young by choice and continue to hide behind it. It is the most obvious obseravtion about the side and is backed by facts. Sure we've had some injuries, but when push comes to shove, we'd rather pick players with less than 5 games experience then pick our depth players WITH experience or mature bodies.
Who are these players you talk about? What facts do you talk about?
List of players with more than 100 games:
8 |
Trengove, Jackson |
186 |
29yr 9mth |
2 Nov 1990 |
197cm |
97kg |
Calder Cannons |
Defender |
1 |
Suckling, Matthew |
177 |
32yr |
25 Jul 1988 |
187cm |
85kg |
Wagga Tigers |
Defender |
10 |
Wood, Easton |
168 |
30yr 11mth |
4 Sep 1989 |
187cm |
86kg |
Camperdown |
Defender |
11 |
Macrae, Jackson |
152 |
26yr |
3 Aug 1994 |
191cm |
85kg |
Oakleigh Chargers |
Midfield |
3 |
Wallis, Mitchell |
144 |
27yr 9mth |
24 Oct 1992 |
186cm |
85kg |
Calder Cannons |
Midfield
Forward |
21 |
Liberatore, Thomas |
141 |
28yr 2mth |
16 May 1992 |
183cm |
83kg |
Calder Cannons |
Midfield |
4 |
Bontempelli, Marcus |
138 |
24yr 8mth |
24 Nov 1995 |
193cm |
93kg |
Northern Knights |
Midfield |
39 |
Johannisen, Jason |
137 |
27yr 9mth |
8 Nov 1992 |
180cm |
82kg |
East Fremantle |
Defender |
15 |
Duryea, Taylor |
132 |
29yr 3mth |
24 Apr 1991 |
179cm |
80kg |
Murray Bushrangers |
Defender |
7 |
Hunter, Lachlan |
131 |
25yr 7mth |
13 Dec 1994 |
183cm |
82kg |
Western Jets |
Midfield |
17 |
Bruce, Josh |
124 |
28yr 2mth |
8 Jun 1992 |
197cm |
101kg |
Canberra |
Forward |
9 |
Crozier, Hayden |
117 |
26yr 7mth |
24 Dec 1993 |
185cm |
79kg |
Eastern Ranges |
Defender |
29 |
Dickson, Tory |
113 |
32yr 10mth |
26 Sep 1987 |
184cm |
85kg |
Bendigo Bombers |
Forward |
35 |
Daniel, Caleb |
102 |
24yr 1mth |
7 J |
Who should be playing and is currently available?
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Originally Posted by
Ozza
Of course we have been young by choice and continue to hide behind it. It is the most obvious obseravtion about the side and is backed by facts. Sure we've had some injuries, but when push comes to shove, we'd rather pick players with less than 5 games experience then pick our depth players WITH experience or mature bodies.
I don't think this helps us develop or build the list either.
Playing Lewis and Lachlan Young and the likes of Greene might have been better for the team
Why do you think we've gone down the option of picking the draftees rather than some of the other younger players?
Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
How about looking at the list above and telling me who are the guys that should be playing? There are only two players that haven't featured the whole season, Trengove (1 game) and Dickson.
Instead of posters having a go at the club for being young, tell me who are the players they wish to see who will not make us young.
50 to 100 game players:
22 |
Lloyd, Sam |
87 |
30yr 5mth |
3 Mar 1990 |
180cm |
81kg |
Frankston |
Forward |
16 |
McLean, Toby |
86 |
24yr 6mth |
31 Jan 1996 |
180cm |
79kg |
Oakleigh Chargers |
Forward |
12 |
Cordy, Zaine |
81 |
23yr 9mth |
27 Oct 1996 |
193cm |
90kg |
Geelong Falcons |
Defender |
5 |
Dunkley, Josh |
71 |
23yr 7mth |
9 Jan 1997 |
190cm |
88kg |
Gippsland Power |
Midfield |
46 |
Jong, Lin |
64 |
27yr 2mth |
4 Jun 1993 |
188cm |
87kg |
Oakleigh Chargers |
Midfield |
31 |
Dale, Bailey |
58 |
24yr |
22 Jul 1996 |
183cm |
82kg |
Dandenong Stingrays |
Forward |
13 |
Schache, Josh |
56 |
22yr 11mth |
21 Aug 1997 |
199cm |
94kg |
Murray Bushrangers |
Forward |
34 |
Williams, Bailey |
52 |
22yr 10mth |
10 Oct 1997 |
187cm |
85kg |
Glenelg |
Defender |
20 |
Richards, Ed |
51 |
21yr 1mth |
3 Jul 1999 |
185cm |
79
|
All playing except Jong and Schache
I don't get why there is this commentary that we are purposely playing young players? We are picking players that are available.
If we play players in the last batch, ie 0 to 50, we will be even more inexperienced????
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 1 Likes
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Best 22 players -Hunter (131) Jong (64), Suckling (177) Duryea (132) have experience but are either injured or out due to other circumstances.
These are facts.
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Originally Posted by
bornadog
Best 22 players -Hunter (131) Jong (64), Suckling (177) Duryea (132) have experience but are either injured or out due to other circumstances.
These are facts.
It is also a fact that we have opted for a younger list.
For varying reasons we have moved on capable players in Hamling, Roughead, Dahlhaus and Stringer but kept players on the list that the coach wouldn't play such as Roberts and Campbell as well as the extraordinary time we have retained rookies like Roarke Smith and Brad Lynch as we did with Josh Prudden.
We could have picked up a delisted free agent like Ricky Henderson or Lachie Henderson instead of hanging on to some of those out of loyalty. There have been opportunities to add more experience, but we have chosen not to do so.
Life is to be Enjoyed not Endured
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 1 Likes
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
I think it's pretty clear that we have chosen to be young through list management decisions.
Given the young list there has been little the selectors can do from week to week to increase the age and experience of the team.
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Its not necessarily about players over 100 games experience. We all know there is more grey area to it BAD. Often it is about choosing the debutant off the back of no form rather than the 2-4 year player who is moved to no-man's land.
We acquired Schache, yet we choose not to play him. If he has one bad game, he is straight out, whereas others get countless chances to prove they don't cut it.
Lewis Young debuted in 2017 and played 7 games. In the following 3 years has played only 8 more games in total. Yet we choose to put Gardner in on the back of proving NOTHING, and looking completely at sea in each and every game.
Tory Dickson has seemingly vanished. But Gowers and Weightman are given 3 chances each. Why keep Tory on the list if players significantly inferior to him and this point in time are preferred. And what was the thinking around drafting a mature age player in Cavarra?
We went after Trengove, now have put a line through him because he doesn't cover the ground. I'm not a big fan, but against sides with very tall forwards, surely he should be getting considered on a horses for courses basis.
We're incredibly keen to rush in some debutants, by far less keen to stick with players in their 2-4 year range and get some continuity into them. But continuity is not really our thing this year clearly. Last year we were the 3rd highest scoring team in the league, and most of our big scores came after a sustained run where the forward line had some continuity as a group with Schache, Dickson, Dale, Naughton and Lloyd all there.
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 3 Likes
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Ozza's point is bang on and is what the numerous posts displaying frustration with a young selection bias mean.
It's a combination of our inability to develop players once on the list, a lack of valueing older role players, and a love for throwing the newest kids at the club into the mix.
I should leave it alone but you're not right
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Originally Posted by
Axe Man
Given the young list there has been little the selectors can do from week to week to increase the age and experience of the team.
Agree
Originally Posted by
Axe Man
I think it's pretty clear that we have chosen to be young through list management decisions.
Originally Posted by
Bulldog Joe
It is also a fact that we have opted for a younger list.
For varying reasons we have moved on capable players in Hamling, Roughead, Dahlhaus and Stringer but kept players on the list that the coach wouldn't play such as Roberts and Campbell as well as the extraordinary time we have retained rookies like Roarke Smith and Brad Lynch as we did with Josh Prudden.
We could have picked up a delisted free agent like Ricky Henderson or Lachie Henderson instead of hanging on to some of those out of loyalty. There have been opportunities to add more experience, but we have chosen not to do so.
We had a number of players either retired or delisted. The List manager has tried hard to bring in experience and over the last 4 odd years we have brought in Suckling, Duryea, Trengove, Lloyd, Bruce and Keath (mature not in games though).
My point is, we aren't trying to be heroes by picking the youngest team every week, it is just the make up we have ended with, and I really don't understand why posters keep harping on about it, or writing to Gerard complaining we are hiding behind it or making it an excuse. It is just a factor we are stuck with for now.
Team selection is a different issue see thread here
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Originally Posted by
soupaman
Ozza's point is bang on and is what the numerous posts displaying frustration with a young selection bias mean.
It's a combination of our inability to develop players once on the list, a lack of valueing older role players, and a love for throwing the newest kids at the club into the mix.
But it is not a young selection bias, we don't have any experienced players like I laid out?
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
I understand your sentiment BAD, and thanks for laying out the (lack of) experience on the list, it's a stark reminder of our predicament. However the point that others are making I think is more a commentary on the progression of players between 0 and 50 games.
To this point I have reservations about our recruiting and development more than our list management.
The guys we've brought in from other clubs have largely served us well - Crozier, Suckling, Duryea, Keath, Lloyd have all I think been fine acquisitions in the right age bracket. Bruce can and will deliver more after getting his body right. Trengove I think deserves more games than he's getting but he's a very limited player and not the answer. Schache can still be a good AFL player but both he and the coaches need to understand his limitations.
Arguably we could have done more to hold onto Roughead, Dahlhaus and Stringer. Hamling we had no hope of keeping. Ditto Adams (injury cursed anyway). Then there's the early retirements of Smith, Redpath, Boyd and Biggs for different reasons out of our control. Overall I think list management in a trading sense gets a 'tick', given the circumstances.
As for recruiting from the drafts, we've done reasonably well with our higher picks in recent years, but our 'roughies' have delivered basically nothing consequential.
Collins, Lynch, Goetz, Lew Young, Greene, Mullenger-McHugh, Prudden (had the talent not the luck), Porter, Gowers, R. Smith, Gardner, Cavarra, Hayes, La. Young, Sweet.
There's still scope for some of the above players to 'make it', but it's not a great track record, and as always it's difficult to assess whether it's a development or recruiting issue. Clearly for me team selection has played some role in stimying some of these players. Lewis Young should 100% be selected ahead of Gardner, who is simply not capable at AFL level (we can all see it, why can't the MC?) Gowers on 2020 form is a liability and has taken games away from Cavarra and Greene, as has Weightman for little return himself.
I'd suggest that quite some number of these guys will be out the door at the end of the year, at the worst possible time, in a compromised draft year. From reports Ugle-Hagan can play but if I understand the bidding system correctly we'll have to shift all of our remaining picks to the back of the draft. That's a big price to pay for a player with no final year of junior footy.
Some interesting times ahead. I pin my hopes on the growth of Richards, English, Lipinski, McLean, Cordy, Dale, Vandermeer and West - all of them can play at AFL level but now need to take another step forward for us to improve.
'And the Western suburbs erupt!'
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 5 Likes
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Originally Posted by
Scorlibo
I understand your sentiment BAD, and thanks for laying out the (lack of) experience on the list, it's a stark reminder of our predicament. However the point that others are making I think is more a commentary on the progression of players between 0 and 50 games.
To this point I have reservations about our recruiting and development more than our list management.
The guys we've brought in from other clubs have largely served us well - Crozier, Suckling, Duryea, Keath, Lloyd have all I think been fine acquisitions in the right age bracket. Bruce can and will deliver more after getting his body right. Trengove I think deserves more games than he's getting but he's a very limited player and not the answer. Schache can still be a good AFL player but both he and the coaches need to understand his limitations.
Arguably we could have done more to hold onto Roughead, Dahlhaus and Stringer. Hamling we had no hope of keeping. Ditto Adams (injury cursed anyway). Then there's the early retirements of Smith, Redpath, Boyd and Biggs for different reasons out of our control. Overall I think list management in a trading sense gets a 'tick', given the circumstances.
As for recruiting from the drafts, we've done reasonably well with our higher picks in recent years, but our 'roughies' have delivered basically nothing consequential.
Collins, Lynch, Goetz, Lew Young, Greene, Mullenger-McHugh, Prudden (had the talent not the luck), Porter, Gowers, R. Smith, Gardner, Cavarra, Hayes, La. Young, Sweet.
There's still scope for some of the above players to 'make it', but it's not a great track record, and as always it's difficult to assess whether it's a development or recruiting issue. Clearly for me team selection has played some role in stimying some of these players. Lewis Young should 100% be selected ahead of Gardner, who is simply not capable at AFL level (we can all see it, why can't the MC?) Gowers on 2020 form is a liability and has taken games away from Cavarra and Greene, as has Weightman for little return himself.
I'd suggest that quite some number of these guys will be out the door at the end of the year, at the worst possible time, in a compromised draft year. From reports Ugle-Hagan can play but if I understand the bidding system correctly we'll have to shift all of our remaining picks to the back of the draft. That's a big price to pay for a player with no final year of junior footy.
Some interesting times ahead. I pin my hopes on the growth of Richards, English, Lipinski, McLean, Cordy, Dale, Vandermeer and West - all of them can play at AFL level but now need to take another step forward for us to improve.
Totally agree with you.
I don't believe recruiting has been as good as we think. Very difficult to get pick one wrong (has happened of course), but the speculative picks haven't been brilliant.
The discussion started off with the comments around we purposely want to look young every week and that is our excuse for losing and stop hiding behind it. Therefore I have proven we don't have the experience we would like.
However, the progress of the 0 to 50 is a concern.
33 |
Naughton, Aaron |
46 |
20yr 8mth |
30 Nov 1999 |
195cm |
89kg |
Peel Thunder |
Forward |
42 |
Keath, Alex |
41 |
28yr 6mth |
20 Jan 1992 |
197cm |
93kg |
Murray Bushrangers |
Defender |
27 |
Lipinski, Patrick |
41 |
22yr |
17 Jul 1998 |
187cm |
84kg |
Northern Knights |
Midfield
Forward |
44 |
English, Timothy |
40 |
23yr |
10 Aug 1997 |
205cm |
93kg |
South Fremantle |
Ruck |
6 |
Smith, Bailey |
34 |
19yr 8mth |
7 Dec 2000 |
185cm |
80kg |
Sandringham Dragons |
Midfield
Forward |
26 |
Gowers, Billy |
33 |
24yr 2mth |
10 Jun 1996 |
187cm |
87kg |
Oakleigh Chargers |
Forward |
37 |
Smith, Roarke R |
18 |
23yr 11mth |
11 Sep 1996 |
181cm |
81kg |
Calder Cannons |
Midfield
Forward |
2 |
Young, Lewis |
15 |
21yr 7mth |
20 Dec 1998 |
197cm |
96kg |
Sturt |
Defender |
23 |
Vandermeer, Laitham |
10 |
21yr 6mth |
3 Feb 1999 |
180cm |
77kg |
Murray Bushrangers |
Midfield
Forward |
32 |
Hayes, Will |
9 |
25yr 2mth |
5 Jun 1995 |
181cm |
77kg |
Footscray Vfl |
Midfield |
36 |
Lynch, Bradley |
9 |
23yr 1mth |
11 Jul 1997 |
187cm |
79kg |
Swan Districts |
Defender |
40 |
Young, Lachie R |
8 |
21yr 4mth |
6 Apr 1999 |
189cm |
81kg |
Mt Eliza Football Netball Club |
Defender |
14 |
West, Rhylee |
6 |
20yr |
12 Jul 2000 |
181cm |
82kg |
Calder Cannons |
Forward |
43 |
Gardner, Ryan R |
5 |
23yr 2mth |
1 Jun 1997 |
197cm |
93kg |
Burnie Dockers |
Forward |
30 |
Greene, Fergus |
5 |
22yr 7mth |
20 Dec 1997 |
187cm |
75kg |
Bendigo Pioneers |
Forward |
19 |
Weightman, Cody |
3 |
19yr 6mth |
15 Jan 2001 |
177cm |
73kg |
Dandenong Stingrays |
Forward |
18 |
Butler, Louis |
2 |
18yr 11mth |
26 Aug 2001 |
184cm |
75kg |
Sandringham Dragons |
Defender
Midfield |
25 |
Cavarra, Ben |
1 |
24yr 7mth |
20 Dec 1995 |
173cm |
72kg |
Williamstown |
Forward |
28 |
Porter, Callum |
1 |
21yr 5mth |
22 Feb 1999 |
182cm |
76kg |
Gippsland Power |
Midfield |
38 |
Garcia, Riley |
0 |
19yr 6mth |
30 Jan 2001 |
177cm |
70kg |
Swan Districts |
Midfield |
24 |
Khamis, Buku R |
0 |
20yr 4mth |
24 Mar 2000 |
189cm |
82kg |
Western Jets |
Defender |
41 |
Sweet, Jordon R |
0 |
22yr 6mth |
2 Feb 1998 |
203cm |
106kg |
North Adelaide |
Ruck |
Hayes, Greene, Gardner, Gowers, Porter, Lynch are a worry. I still have hope for Lew Young, and there are some untried players there. Overall not a lot to worry about as we normally delist about 7 to 8 per year.
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 1 Likes
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
The problem with the side isn't age it's balance.
There is a reason when opposition sides get a run on we can't stop the momentum. We just have too many of the same type
of players/characters.
There are a number of players that Bevo loves for what they bring when we are rolling, but they don't offer much defensively.
ie Dale, McLean, JJ, Macrae, Lipinski, Daniel, Bont, Richards, as an example are all very much attacking players, but once the ball has left the contest, they aren't big chase down defensive players.
We get scored against way too easily on the rebound because we aren't prepared to work hard enough the other way to get the ball back.
I just think the balance isn't quite there at the moment, we are a couple of hard nuts through middle short. You can also add that Dunkley is not at his best since the recent injury, Bont isn't moving like he should, Smith is probably getting more attention and is having lean patch, same with English. Without our engine room at it's best, i think we have too many light bodied players that don't want to run hard defensively and this is exposing us.
Lin Jong is a great example. Earlier in the year he was throwing himself into contests and providing a defensive threat, adding pressure, and we were starting to play some good football that was enabling the creative players to shine.
We lose Dunkley and Jong who are 2 of our strongest bodied runners, and we bring in Dale, Lipinski, Lloyd effectively as replacements.
You can also add the poor selection of a 3rd defensive option at many times this year. Why we keep going for Gardner is beyond me. Not sure who thought he would be a better match up for Hipwood than either of the Youngs or even Khamis. Hipwood is a leading forward not a big marking one, yet we went for Gardner and he was lost at sea.
I don't think it's all doom and gloom however, we just need to adjust things a little to get ourselves back on track.
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 6 Likes
-
Re: Scratch match wrap | Dogs v Lions
Originally Posted by
Cyberdoggie
The problem with the side isn't age it's balance.
There is a reason when opposition sides get a run on we can't stop the momentum. We just have too many of the same type
of players/characters.
There are a number of players that Bevo loves for what they bring when we are rolling, but they don't offer much defensively.
ie Dale, McLean, JJ, Macrae, Lipinski, Daniel, Bont, Richards, as an example are all very much attacking players, but once the ball has left the contest, they aren't big chase down defensive players.
We get scored against way too easily on the rebound because we aren't prepared to work hard enough the other way to get the ball back.
I just think the balance isn't quite there at the moment, we are a couple of hard nuts through middle short. You can also add that Dunkley is not at his best since the recent injury, Bont isn't moving like he should, Smith is probably getting more attention and is having lean patch, same with English. Without our engine room at it's best, i think we have too many light bodied players that don't want to run hard defensively and this is exposing us.
Lin Jong is a great example. Earlier in the year he was throwing himself into contests and providing a defensive threat, adding pressure, and we were starting to play some good football that was enabling the creative players to shine.
We lose Dunkley and Jong who are 2 of our strongest bodied runners, and we bring in Dale, Lipinski, Lloyd effectively as replacements.
You can also add the poor selection of a 3rd defensive option at many times this year. Why we keep going for Gardner is beyond me. Not sure who thought he would be a better match up for Hipwood than either of the Youngs or even Khamis. Hipwood is a leading forward not a big marking one, yet we went for Gardner and he was lost at sea.
I don't think it's all doom and gloom however, we just need to adjust things a little to get ourselves back on track.
Agree with all you have said.
Just a reminder, Buku is only 189cm, Hipwood is 204cm
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.