Match Committee - Round 17, 2017 vs Carlton

[Rocco Jones]

I'd say Honeychurch to tag Docherty but we don't do that kind of thing. Really struggling to get the Honeychurch call, he has stunk it up big time the last two weeks.

[always right]

I'd say Honeychurch to tag Docherty but we don't do that kind of thing. Really struggling to get the Honeychurch call, he has stunk it up big time the last two weeks.

Last chance to play a Dickson type role as a defensive forward.

[jeemak]

I didn't know Dickson was a defencive forward.

Honey has only had one good half in a month of football, and I'd put a line through him after a few really poor efforts last week. It's probably a bit of an indicator of how ordinary those in the seconds are going I suppose.

[Rocket Science]

I want to see Redpath kick 5 on Jones and smash him.

That'd be lovely...but tall, athletic defenders who can intercept our aimless lobs forward are our kryptonite at the moment. Even when their name's Liam Jones I fear.

This game's going to shit me to tears.

[always right]

I didn't know Dickson was a defencive forward.

Honey has only had one good half in a month of football, and I'd put a line through him after a few really poor efforts last week. It's probably a bit of an indicator of how ordinary those in the seconds are going I suppose.

Not a defensive role in the truest sense but having some accountability for their opponent, which is what Dickson has done often.

[Doc26]

How is Honeychurch still in this side?

... I'm tipping Carltank.

Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results

[bornadog]

That'd be lovely...but tall, athletic defenders who can intercept our aimless lobs forward are our kryptonite at the moment. Even when their name's Liam Jones I fear.

This game's going to shit me to tears.

Redpath can get his hands on the ball, just needs to convert

[jeemak]

Not a defensive role in the truest sense but having some accountability for their opponent, which is what Dickson has done often.

Fair enough, I've always considered Dickson to be more of a space finding forward target who can sometimes get onto a loose ball. Every player on the list needs to do the defencive stuff when needed, perhaps we've taken Dickson away from the former and it's why he's struggled a bit to get into the game (aside from our disgusting forward movement hampering his ability to do so).

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Our premiership last year is on for footy flashbacks before our game Sunday

[Remi Moses]

I just don't get why Honeychurch is getting a gig .
I know Bevo is loyal, but this is rediculous

[Eastdog]

Redpath can get his hands on the ball, just needs to convert

Redders has been a positive this season certainly giving us some structure up forward. Would be great if he could get a some goals on Sunday and dominant up there.

[jeemak]

I just don't get why Honeychurch is getting a gig .
I know Bevo is loyal, but this is rediculous

Who's performed better than he has over an extended period and who deserves to play in his spot?

As I said earlier, his continued selection is more of an indictment of our reserve stocks than it is on our selection of him.

[hujsh]

I just don't get why Honeychurch is getting a gig .
I know Bevo is loyal, but this is rediculous

Possibly an Ayce Cordy situation?

Give him every chance to show he can play before putting the line through him

[Remi Moses]

Possibly an Ayce Cordy situation?

Give him every chance to show he can play before putting the line through him

Thinking the same thing . Surely Lipinski or Hamilton

[Remi Moses]

Who's performed better than he has over an extended period and who deserves to play in his spot?

As I said earlier, his continued selection is more of an indictment of our reserve stocks than it is on our selection of him.

Hamilton deserves a run, although I think Honey played better at the lower level than Hamilton .
Honey's had an extended run and has been ordinary . If we're going to see what players bring for a period of time isn't it time w had a look at Hamilton .