PDA

View Full Version : Brent Prismall joins Dogs


Pedro Sanchez
21-12-2012, 05:55 PM
Seems as though B-Mac eventually got his man... http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/bulldogs-recruit-prismall-20121221-2bqsp.html

If he's as good as the reports say re being a top bloke, another good get for the club. Wouldn't mind knowing how many new coaches and support staff we've appointed this off season. Surely a record for the club.

off the top I can think of the following:


Ben Graham
Scarlett
Mooney
Johnno
Prismall
Hansen
Eastdog
21-12-2012, 05:58 PM
We definitely were looking to get him and now we have. Do you rate him PS? He might show his potential now his joined us.
Pedro Sanchez
21-12-2012, 06:30 PM
We definitely were looking to get him and now we have. Do you rate him PS? He might show his potential now his joined us.

Potential as a player or coach? If it’s the former well we’ll have to see how he goes at Willi as he wont be eligible for the senior side. And in terms of player development the proof will be in how the young guys kick on.

It’s worth noting though that the current squad is probably an easier proposition to manage and mentor given there isn’t anyone from remote outback Australia. No Xephi Skinner’s for example.

Anyway I hope he’s a great success and instrumental in our premiership success in 2013. Boom ;)
The Underdog
21-12-2012, 06:43 PM
Potential as a player or coach? If it’s the former well we’ll have to see how he goes at Willi as he wont be eligible for the senior side. And in terms of player development the proof will be in how the young guys kick on.

It’s worth noting though that the current squad is probably an easier proposition to manage and mentor given there isn’t anyone from remote outback Australia. No Xephi Skinner’s for example.

Anyway I hope he’s a great success and instrumental in our premiership success in 2013. Boom ;)

Hopefully he can help Brett Goodes in his transition to AFL football. And Goodes can help him transition into his role.
Eastdog
21-12-2012, 06:45 PM
Potential as a player or coach? If it’s the former well we’ll have to see how he goes at Willi as he wont be eligible for the senior side. And in terms of player development the proof will be in how the young guys kick on.

It’s worth noting though that the current squad is probably an easier proposition to manage and mentor given there isn’t anyone from remote outback Australia. No Xephi Skinner’s for example.

Anyway I hope he’s a great success and instrumental in our premiership success in 2013. Boom ;)

I'd say both. Are we getting him as a player or a coach. Is this his first time at coaching if we are getting him as a coach.
AndrewP6
21-12-2012, 06:56 PM
I'd say both. Are we getting him as a player or a coach. Is this his first time at coaching if we are getting him as a coach.

He's playing with Williamstown.
Pedro Sanchez
21-12-2012, 07:02 PM
He's playing with Williamstown.

Yep. He's role is player welfare - so not a coach or a first team player. However if he has a stella year injury free at Willi, then who knows... He could do a Goodes and become a mature-aged rookie.
Greystache
21-12-2012, 07:02 PM
I expect this to be a dual role for the club. Player welfare manager and VFL player/coach, we'll be needing players like Prismall when we start fielding a stand alone team in 2014.
bulldogtragic
21-12-2012, 07:47 PM
I expect this to be a dual role for the club. Player welfare manager and VFL player/coach, we'll be needing players like Prismall when we start fielding a stand alone team in 2014.
Could be Footscrays first captain in 2014. Also sounds like he will be the counter balance to influences like Sherman. That can only be a good thing.

I also wonder whether he is really happy for this opportunity or whether he regrets not taking the one year offer from the dons or port. Surely there would be some regret.
Greystache
21-12-2012, 07:50 PM
Could be Footscrays first captain in 2014. Also sounds like he will be the counter balance to influences like Sherman. That can only be a good thing.

It wouldn't surprise me BT, if he can get his body right he could be similar to Ben Jolley which would be a fantastic result. We could do with another couple of his type over the next year and a bit.
GVGjr
22-12-2012, 08:57 AM
I get the impression that a lot of decisions are made with the longer term view and especially around setting up our VFL side in 2014.
LostDoggy
22-12-2012, 11:42 AM
Why the knock on Sherman?
EasternWest
22-12-2012, 12:40 PM
Why the knock on Sherman?

Because he's an idiot?
Rocco Jones
22-12-2012, 01:18 PM
I get the impression that a lot of decisions are made with the longer term view and especially around setting up our VFL side in 2014.

Yep. Obviously Prismall but Hansen is a fair chance too. Hansen kicked 67 goals in 14 games in the WAFL this year. He will be only 30 going into 2014. Perhaps Gia could be an option too.

With quickly changing game, I like the idea of having a specialist coach or two/welfare guy spends time with our kids where it matters most, on the field.

Collingwood hardly need to be economical in this aspect but still do with Hahn this year and Hudson next year.
GVGjr
23-12-2012, 07:44 AM
Why the knock on Sherman?

He's not an AFL player because he just doesn't have the dedication required. He's talented enough.


Because he's an idiot?

I'm not so sure about that. He could have potted the club on his departure but instead he did and said the right things.
It was a far cry in comparison to Akermanis.
GVGjr
23-12-2012, 07:49 AM
Yep. Obviously Prismall but Hansen is a fair chance too. Hansen kicked 67 goals in 14 games in the WAFL this year. He will be only 30 going into 2014. Perhaps Gia could be an option too.

With quickly changing game, I like the idea of having a specialist coach or two/welfare guy spends time with our kids where it matters most, on the field.



I hadn't considered Hansen as an on field option I wonder if he would enough have the time to train but I do like your idea of having some coaches playing on match day in the VFL.
EasternWest
23-12-2012, 11:02 AM
I'm not so sure about that. He could have potted the club on his departure but instead he did and said the right things.
It was a far cry in comparison to Akermanis.

He's definitely an idiot, but certainly not in the same malicious mode.

I'm sure he's a reasonable enough guy, but his history is littered with enough evidence of stupid things to confirm that he's a bit of a dunderhead.
Rocco Jones
23-12-2012, 12:44 PM
I hadn't considered Hansen as an on field option I wonder if he would enough have the time to train but I do like your idea of having some coaches playing on match day in the VFL.

Yeah seems like all sides are moving into have development coaches for each line who are younger. I think there's a few things we can do with our VFL top ups.