Woof Player Awards Rnd 18 - Western Bulldogs vs North Melbourne

[BulldogBelle]

R18 - Western Bulldogs vs North Melbourne

There are two awards that you can vote on, once the game is completed.

Voting closes each Tuesday at 8.00pm.

The first one is for the Joe Marmo Medal for the best players on the ground.

There are 4 votes allocated and it's a 4 for the best and of course 3, 2 and 1.

and

The second award is for the Ron James Medal for the best 2 pups on the ground.

2 Votes allocated - 2 being for the best pup and 1 for the runner-up
Remember the cut off age for a pup is 22 as at the 1st of January, 2010.

Pups available for selection -

Jarrod Boumann, Ayce Cordy, Jamason Daniels, Andrejs Everitt, Jarrad Grant, Jarrod Harbrow, Shaun Higgins, Josh Hill, Andrew Hooper, Christian Howard, Liam Jones, James Mulligan, Matthew Panos, Eddie Prato, Sam J Reid, Jordan Roughead, Brennan Stack, Jason Tutt, Callan Ward, Easton Wood.

Need to know more - History of WOOF Awards and Voting Rules (http://www.woof.net.au/forum/showthread.php?t=7099)

[GVGjr]

Marmo
4 - Liam Picken
3 - Matthew Boyd
2 - Lindsay Gilbee
1 - Daniel Cross

James
2 - Roughead
1 - Higgins

[LostDoggy]

4. Hall
3. Boyd
2. Lake
1. Wood
Prime Minister Gillard just missed out on getting a vote!

2. Wood
1. Roughead

[AndrewP6]

4 Bazza
3 Gia
2 Boyd
1 Cross

2 Roughy
1 Wood

[Bumper Bulldogs]

Marmo
4 - Boyd
3 - Cross
2 - Hall
1 - Gilbee

James
2 - Roughy
1 - Wood

[choconmientay]

4 Bazza
3 Boyd
2 Picken
1 Griffen

2 Roughy
1 Wood

[G-Mo77]

Tough to pick 4 this week.

4 - Boyd
3 - Cross
2 - Hall
1 - Picken

(Sorry Gia)

2. Roughead
1. Wood

[jazzadogs]

4 Hall
3 Boyd
2 Gia
1 Cooney

2 Roughead
1 Wood

[Happy Days]

4. Boyd
3. Hall
2. Gia
1. Griffen

2. Wood
1. Roughead

[Go_Dogs]

4. Picken
3. Hall
2. Johnson
1. Boyd

2. Grant
1. Roughead

[G-Mo77]

4. Picken
3. Hall
2. Johnson
1. Boyd

2. Grant
1. Roughead

I'm glad someone else thought he was really good today. I wanted to squeeze him in but just couldn't.

[Greystache]

4. Hall
3. Boyd
2. Gia
1. Griffen


2. Roughead
1. Wood

[Flamethrower]

4. Hall
3. Boyd
2. Lake
1. Wood
Prime Minister Gillard just missed out on getting a vote!

2. Wood
1. Roughead

She would prefer your vote on August 28th!

4 - Matty Boyd
3 - Barry Hall
2 - Daniel Giansiracusa
1 - Adam Cooney

2 - Jordan Roughead
1 - Easton Wood

[LostDoggy]

4. Boyd
3. Hall
2. Gia
1. Johnson

2. Grant
1. Roughead

[Doggy]

4 Boyd
3 Hall
2 Picken
1 Johnno

2 Wood
1 Grant
__________________

[LostDoggy]

4. Hall
3. Cross
2. Giansiracusa
1. Hargrave

2. Wood
1. Everitt

Boyd 40+ touches but just too many turnovers IMO..

[Hotdog60]

4 - Liam Picken
3 - Barry Hall
2 - Daniel Giansiracusa
1 - Adam Cooney

Apologies to Boyd, Johnson, Gilbee, Griffen and Hudson

2 - Jordan Roughead
1 - Easton Wood

[BulldogBelle]

4 Hall
3 Gia
2 Griff
1 Boyd

2 Williams
1 Grant

[Hotdog60]

4 Hall
3 Gia
2 Griff
1 Boyd

2 Williams
1 Grant

I don't think Tom is a Pup.

[Rance Fan]

4 Gia
3 Boyd
2 Hall
1 Griffen

2 Roughead
1 Wood

[Ozza]

4. Boyd
3. Hall
2. Morris
1. Gia

rj

2. Higgins
1. Wood

[LostDoggy]

Marmo
4 - Liam Picken
3 - Matthew Boyd
2 - Lindsay Gilbee
1 - Daniel Cross

James
2 - Roughead
1 - Higgins

Good work GVG, Picken is an out and out gun.

[boydogs]

Good work GVG, Picken is an out and out gun.

Interesting to see 3 posters have given him BOG, but 12 posters haven't given him a single vote

[GVGjr]

Interesting to see 3 posters have given him BOG, but 12 posters haven't given him a single vote

I can sort of see why though. We had 40% of all out tackles made by just 2 players and I thought that was worth a special mention. Perhaps I have over rated his effort today

[The Coon Dog]

4/ Barry Hall
3/ Daniel Giansiracusa
2/ Daniel Cross
1/ Lindsay Gilbee

[LostDoggy]

4.Gia
3. Morris
2..Boyd... got us going in the 3q
1.. BBB Hall

The champs back .. good game Johnno

2. Roughy
1. Grant

[Greystache]

4/ Barry Hall
3/ Daniel Giansiracusa
2/ Daniel Cross
1/ Lindsay Gilbee

Can I ask TCD why you never vote on the pups?

[LostDoggy]

Interesting to see 3 posters have given him BOG, but 12 posters haven't given him a single vote

Tagged Harvey who had enough of the ball and 3 goals. Break even for mine on the day

[EasternWest]

I can sort of see why though. We had 40% of all out tackles made by just 2 players and I thought that was worth a special mention. Perhaps I have over rated his effort today

No, you haven't.


Good work GVG, Picken is an out and out gun.

Yes, he is.


Tagged Harvey who had enough of the ball and 3 goals. Break even for mine on the day

Harvey had two of his goals gifted to him through no fault of Picken's. Except for the brief period when he kicked his two goals on top of each other, he had little impact on the game. I rate Harvey, he's still very dangerous, and that's why I thought Picken did such a good job.

4. Picken
3. Cross
2. Hall
1. Gia

Gotta agree with an earlier poster, Boyd had so much of the ball, but some bad turnovers. It's not the hurried kick that bothers me, it's the duffed one to a leading Hall and the uncontested one straight onto a North players chest. Love Boyd, but would love to see that area improved.

2. Roughead
1. Wood

I actually though Grant looked a bit down today.

[Go_Dogs]

I can sort of see why though. We had 40% of all out tackles made by just 2 players and I thought that was worth a special mention. Perhaps I have over rated his effort today

I thought the general contributions across the best 5 or 6 were pretty even, so it wasn't that easy to give just 4 votes and to order them.

Like you say, Picken had a very good defensive game, and he was involved in winning a lot of contested ball and a number of clearances. His general ability to be involved and help create something offensively has improved a lot, and he's really combining the negating and attacking aspects just about to perfection at the moment.

[EasternWest]

I thought the general contributions across the best 5 or 6 were pretty even, so it wasn't that easy to give just 4 votes and to order them.

Like you say, Picken had a very good defensive game, and he was involved in winning a lot of contested ball and a number of clearances. His general ability to be involved and help create something offensively has improved a lot, and he's really combining the negating and attacking aspects just about to perfection at the moment.

I've been pleasantly surprised with his skills. He's deceptively agile, doesn't often lose his feet and is good by hand and foot. Not bad for a bargain basement kid.

[LostDoggy]

27 possesions 3 goals for Harvey not a blanket stop

[EasternWest]

27 possesions 3 goals for Harvey not a blanket stop

No, I agree. Like I said, I don't think Picken was to blame for two of them. If Harvey walks away from a game on Liam with 27 and 1 (and little influence), I'll take that. I think Harvey is too good a player to totally remove from a game, but to quell his influence is a win IMO.

[LostDoggy]

No, I agree. Like I said, I don't think Picken was to blame for two of them. If Harvey walks away from a game on Liam with 27 and 1 (and little influence), I'll take that. I think Harvey is too good a player to totally remove from a game, but to quell his influence is a win IMO.

Good game from Picks but not in the votes for mine

[Remi Moses]

Harvey got a few cheapies. I thought Liam was good

5. Barry
4.Boydy
3.Griffen
2.picken
1.Gia

saw a few really pleasing desperate acts from Gia in front of me
Could have given the Norf fan who bothered to turn up a vote!!
Honestly there were more Adelaide fans at Etihad earlier in the year!

2. Roughy
1. Johnno (just kidding)

[GVGjr]

Harvey got a few cheapies. I thought Liam was good

5. Barry
4.Boydy
3.Griffen
2.picken
1.Gia

saw a few really pleasing desperate acts from Gia in front of me
Could have given the Norf fan who bothered to turn up a vote!!
Honestly there were more Adelaide fans at Etihad earlier in the year!

2. Roughy
1. Johnno (just kidding)

FYI, The Marmo only has 4 votes.

[LostDoggy]

4. Ben Huddo
3. Ryan Griffen
2. Barry Hall
1. Tom Williams

2. Jordan Roughead
1. Easton Wood

[bornadog]

4. Boyd - 40 possessions, had the ball on a string, although some bad turnovers as well.
3. Hall - 7 goals and two posters, great effort, but the players upfield feeding him deserve most of the credit.
2. Hudson, dominated the ruck with 20 hitouts plus was very good around the ground.
1. Gia - 5 goals, good game, attacked the ball so well today.

2. Roughead - improving every week.
1. Grant - started slowly but finished off well.

[Scorlibo]

4 - Boyd
3 - Morris
2 - Hall
1 - Griffen

Apologies to Gia, Cross, Hudson, Picken (would have got votes had Harvey not been as good as he was).

2 - Higgins
1 - Roughead

[BulldogBelle]

4. Boyd
3. Hudson
2. Cooney
1. Hall

2. Roughie
1. Wood

Boy that was ridiculously hard.

[chef]

4. Cross
3. Hall
2. Griffen
1. Giansiracusa

[LostDoggy]

4) Boyd
3) Gia
2) Baz
1) Picken

(with apologies to quite a few - Johnno, Crossy, Griff, Huddo)

2) Roughhead
1) Wood

[always right]

4. Hall (four quarters of dominance)
3. Boyd (second half was outstanding)
2. Morris (ultra-reliable when things weren't going well in the first half)
1. Johnno (perhaps a little generous but he seemed to have his old spark back)

[KT31]

4 Gia
3 Bazza
2 Boyd
1 Johnno

2 Roughy
1 Wood

[cambo]

4 Picken
3 Hall
2 Griff
1 Boyd

2 Roughy
1 Grant

[Mofra]

4. Hall
3. Gia
2. Boyd
1. Griffen

2. Roughy
1. Wood

[Lurgan]

4. Griffen
3. Boyd
2. Hall
1. Giansiracusa

2. Roughead
1. Higgins

[Jasper]

4. Hall
3. Boyd
2. Gia
1. Griffen

2. Roughead
1. Wood

[Sedat]

Marmo:

4. Hall
3. Giansiracusa
2. Boyd
1. Hudson

James:

2. Higgins
1. Roughead

[LostDoggy]

4. Boyd
3. Gia ( that's as hard as i've seen him go)
2.Hally
1. Griffo

2.Roughy
1. Wood

[Doc26]

4. Hall
3. Boyd
2. Cross
1. Giansiracusa

[BulldogBelle]

4 Hall
3 Boyd
2 Gia
1 Cross

2 Roughy
1 Wood

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Marmo

4. Boyd
3. Cross
2. Griffen
1. Picken

James

2. Higgins
1. Roughead

[BulldogBelle]

Marmo
4 - B Hall
3 - D Giansiracusa
2 - D Cross
1 - M Boyd

Apologies to a few others.

James
2 - J Roughead
1 - E Wood

[Chicago1]

Based upon watching on my computer screen:

4 - Hall
3 - Cross
2 - Giansiracusa
1 - Boyd

[BulldogBelle]

Voting is now closed.