Originally Posted by
Bulldog Joe
Sorry Twodogs, but is an emphatic NO from me.
As others have said, he is passed it.
Redpath is already better in the following ways
1. Mobility and it is not Jack's greatest strength.
2. Adaptability - Jack can take a turn in the ruck and be competitive. Jack could also go back and play as a KPD if it became necessary in a game.
3. Tackling - Jack brings real intent with his aggression.
4. Kicking - Jack is capable in front of goals and generally a reliable shot.
5. Personality - Jack is not a Cloke.