Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
I've discounted Malthouse on his last couple of seasons.
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Twodogs
1. Bevo
2. Wallace
3. Eade
2. Hampshire
1. Rose
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Twodogs
But Wheeler must be up there. I don't think he had a less than 50/50 season did he?
Do you wish to revise your list?
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
westdog54
Do you wish to revise your list?
Thank you. No. That is I probably should, but my head would explode,
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
1. Bevo
2. Wallace
3. Eade
4. Rose
5. Joyce
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Deleted post. Didn't read quesition properly.
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PeanutsPeanuts
Can't think who the 100% man is, but Paul Williams at 66% would have to be Number 2. For 3,4 and 5 I'll go Bevo, Wheels and Norm Ware (captain coached successfully in a couple of the war years). Reckon Rocket and Plough would be thereabouts also.
I think the question says the coach has had to be there for the season at least. The 100% man is a separate question
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Oops re-read the question:
Bevo
Wheels
Ware
Eade
Olliver
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Who was the caretaker after Wallace left?. The last game for the season v Collingwood, pretty sure we won
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
Who was the caretaker after Wallace left?. The last game for the season v Collingwood, pretty sure we won
From memory that was Rohde (who won't be on this list).
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
Who was the caretaker after Wallace left?. The last game for the season v Collingwood, pretty sure we won
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PeanutsPeanuts
From memory that was Rohde (who won't be on this list).
It was Rohde but maybe our man is David Noble? Did he go 1 for 1?
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Twodogs
1. Bevo
2. Wallace
3. Eade
2. Hampshire
1. Rose
One correct. One wrong spot.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
1. Bevo
2. Wallace
3. Eade
4. Rose
5. Joyce
As above.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PeanutsPeanuts
Oops re-read the question:
Bevo
Wheels
Ware
Eade
Olliver
Ooh not bad, one correct, three wrong spots.
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
Who was the caretaker after Wallace left?. The last game for the season v Collingwood, pretty sure we won
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PeanutsPeanuts
From memory that was Rohde (who won't be on this list).
Rhode was the one match caretaker for Wallace. Obviously he didn't remain at 100%.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Twodogs
It was Rohde but maybe our man is David Noble? Did he go 1 for 1?
Its not Noble.
TBH, if you don't get this I don't think anyone will.
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
One correct. One wrong spot.
Alright we can assume the #1 spot is Bevo, so having sat down with pen and paper and after some discussions via text I have come up with a rough win/loss as best as I can remember it the list is;
1\ Bevo
2\ Cubbins (Both over 60%)
3\ Eade
4\ Wallace
5\ Wheeler
It's lucky I have a long standing interest in Bill Cubbins.
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Im racking my brains on the one game one win guy. Is it Wally Donald?
If not are there any clues?
Re: Who Am I? - 2017 Off Season, Full Version
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Twodogs
Im racking my brains on the one game one win guy. Is it Wally Donald?
If not are there any clues?
Donald isn't a bad guess but he's 1 win two losses.
Like Donald, it was Charlie Sutton that this man filled in for in the early 50s.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Twodogs
Alright we can assume the #1 spot is Bevo, so having sat down with pen and paper and after some discussions via text I have come up with a rough win/loss as best as I can remember it the list is;
1\ Bevo
2\ Cubbins (Both over 60%)
3\ Eade
4\ Wallace
5\ Wheeler
It's lucky I have a long standing interest in Bill Cubbins.
One correct. Three wrong spot. The one you're missing has been nominated already.