Re: Other club trade talk
Twitter seems to have a view WCE could trade Gaff to get Kelly, a pick to assist it. If this was a real thing (IF), I wonder if our pick 13 - giving them back to back picks 13 & 14 to offer for Tim Kelly (Picks 22 & 33 up their sleves) is enough to get him. 27yo, gut running winger with great skills. IF it’s something WCE are doing, it could be an interesting development.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bulldogtragic
Twitter seems to have a view WCE could trade Gaff to get Kelly, a pick to assist it. If this was a real thing (IF), I wonder if our pick 13 - giving them back to back picks 13 & 14 to offer for Tim Kelly (Picks 22 & 33 up their sleves) is enough to get him. 27yo, gut running winger with great skills. IF it’s something WCE are doing, it could be an interesting development.
Gaff for 13 yes please. Precisely what we are looking for. But won't be enough to get him I'd say.
Re: Other club trade talk
Kelly nominated Eagles officially according to the age. How on earth are they going to do that deal?
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Grantysghost
Kelly nominated Eagles officially according to the age. How on earth are they going to do that deal?
Pick 13 and a player of ours/another pick to WCE or Geelong for Andrew Gaff.
Picks 13 & 14 (22 & 33 or the dogs or WCE player) for Tim Kelly.
I'm just trying to be helpful. I don't like when people argue. So if that helps everyone else, I guess we should do the right thing.
I.e. I don't want McLean traded, but 13 & McLean for Gaff & 33 (36 after compo, 40+ after matched bids). Pick 13, 14 & McLean for Tim Kelly. WCE still hold 22 with Kelly, but lose Gaff.
Re: Other club trade talk
I can't see any sense in West Coast trading Gaff to get Kelly in. It's an upgrade but not at the expense of pick 14 as well.
I think this years and next years first rounders would be around the mark. Otherwise they need to trade a couple of fringe players like Petrucele for mid range picks and move up the draft order.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Axe Man
I can't see any sense in West Coast trading Gaff to get Kelly in. It's an upgrade but not at the expense of pick 14 as well.
I think this years and next years first rounders would be around the mark. Otherwise they need to trade a couple of fringe players like Petrucele for mid range picks and move up the draft order.
I’m just trying to be helpful to them all for a 2020 free agent who may make it hard if the reported $800,000 salary puts pressure on their cap. Geelong should aim to bring in someone through this trade who wants and play serious midfield minutes and can kick a goal. A team who can bring that and a juicy pick could be rewarded.
I’m not betting on it. Just being helpful to clubs in disagreement. They tried to use us last year, and we said no. I’m happy to be sounded out again if they think we can help, for real this time.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bulldogtragic
I’m just trying to be helpful to them all for a 2020 free agent who may make it hard if the reported $800,000 salary puts pressure on their cap. Geelong should aim to bring in someone through this trade who wants and play serious midfield minutes and can kick a goal. A team who can bring that and a juicy pick could be rewarded.
I’m not betting on it. Just being helpful to clubs in disagreement. They tried to use us last year, and we said no. I’m happy to be sounded out again if they think we can help, for real this time.
They got Dalhaus , I believe he kicked a goal sometime during the year ;-)
Re: Other club trade talk
Would love Gaff. Him out for Kelly in seems idiotic, particularly after they went so hard to keep him last year.
Trade period is fascinating. Geelong in the Dangerfield trade were all “he wants to come home, Adelaide can’t expect the kitchen sink” now with Kelly they want the kitchen sink.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Grantysghost
Kelly nominated Eagles officially according to the age. How on earth are they going to do that deal?
1st pick this year and next year.
2017 1st round pick Jarrod Brander.
Geelong's choice of Duggan, Ainsworth or Venables - other recent 1st and 2nd round picks.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AshMac
Would love Gaff. Him out for Kelly in seems idiotic, particularly after they went so hard to keep him last year.
Trade period is fascinating. Geelong in the Dangerfield trade were all “he wants to come home, Adelaide can’t expect the kitchen sink” now with Kelly they want the kitchen sink.
Thinking the same thing
God I hate the bluster and posturing this time of year
Re: Other club trade talk
I don't believe Gaff is going anywhere, just made up by people trying to work out a trade.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
mjp
1st pick this year and next year.
2017 1st round pick Jarrod Brander.
Geelong's choice of Duggan, Ainsworth or Venables - other recent 1st and 2nd round picks.
Duggan is a Bacchus Marsh boy, Geelong would be an ideal spot for him if he wanted to come home.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
westdog54
Duggan is a Bacchus Marsh boy, Geelong would be an ideal spot for him if he wanted to come home.
If Duggan goes to Geelong it makes the Charlie Constable situation interesting.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
Where has it been confirmed he's requested the trade?
Depends what constitutes a 'request' but appears the wheels are in motion.
I'm guessing Joe's treading softly in public to placate an already broken fanbase of a club his name's synonymous with, and not provide Bombres brass further reason to obstruct a move because, y'know, they have to 'win' trade week.
I'm still agog Essendon have let it come to this with Daniher. Imagine us confronting this with Libba or Rhylee West in a few years.
Re: Other club trade talk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rocket Science
Depends what constitutes a 'request' but appears the
wheels are in motion.
I'm guessing Joe's treading softly in public to placate an already broken fanbase of a club his name's synonymous with, and not provide Bombres brass further reason to obstruct a move because, y'know, they have to 'win' trade week.
I'm still agog Essendon have let it come to this with Daniher. Imagine us confronting this with Libba or Rhylee West in a few years.
Danihers also played at Swans.