Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Karl Amon FA to Hawthorn - compensation is a second round pick (currently 27)
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
jazzadogs
Karl Amon FA to Hawthorn - compensation is a second round pick (currently 27)
Just a second rounder? Sounds like that's the most Brisbane can hope for from McStay then
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hujsh
Just a second rounder? Sounds like that's the most Brisbane can hope for from McStay then
They’re not going to be thrilled with Pick 35. I suppose they bank the draft points and move on. Would’ve been better for us, but broadly, I don’t mind tighter compo levels.
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hujsh
Just a second rounder? Sounds like that's the most Brisbane can hope for from McStay then
I thought the hopes of a first rounder for Amon and McStay were optimistic.
FYI this is how the compensation is determined:
Quote:
HOW IS FREE AGENCY ASSESSED?
The compensation is based purely on guaranteed money and a ranking system where every player in the AFL aged 25 or older is placed in order.
The highest-paid player has a value of 100 points, with extra points added for a player’s age (less points are added for an older player) with a maximum points value of 112 points.
First-round compensation picks are handed out for players in the top five per cent based on that points score, with end-of-first-round compensation for players within the top five to 15 per cent.
Second-round picks are for players in the 15-30 per cent band and end-of-second-round picks for players in the 30-50 band.
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Axe Man
I thought the hopes of a first rounder for Amon and McStay were optimistic.
FYI this is how the compensation is determined:
I think the idea of getting a 1st round pick was based on precedents like Motlop. Given what you posted it could be that they didn't reach that level since the pay levels have increased overall or the brackets have shifted around in some way (or a bit of both)
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hujsh
I think the idea of getting a 1st round pick was based on precedents like Motlop. Given what you posted it could be that they didn't reach that level since the pay levels have increased overall or the brackets have shifted around in some way (or a bit of both)
I understand why the clubs will point to things like that and the rest of us are left confused but the Motlop case should be filed under 2 wrongs don't make a right.
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Axe Man
I thought the hopes of a first rounder for Amon and McStay were optimistic.
FYI this is how the compensation is determined:
Dan McStay is also a year older, and contract is less - but surely they don't get less than a 2nd rounder...
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
jazzadogs
Dan McStay is also a year older, and contract is less - but surely they don't get less than a 2nd rounder...
AFL may as well troll everyone and give Brisbane an end of first round pick. Think of all the engagement it will drive.
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Liam Jones manager overseas, so expected trade on Monday
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Bobby Hill and pick 40 sent to the Magpies for a future second-round selection and pick 43 in this year’s draft.
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
Surely this means Dunkley is worth two first round picks. It’s undeniable now
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Scraggers
Surely this means Dunkley is worth two first round picks. It’s undeniable now
There is precedent now and any reasonable valuation should see that.
Re: Confirmed Trades 2022
7 and 15 sounds right now