Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
No the word is lumbering.
Jury still out on Dale. He was playing shocking footy and had been on the list for 7 years. Saved himself With a couple of good games but needs to back it up.
On Harley, yes I would give a potential A grader a go
I don't get your selection criteria. Jenkins has has often kicked more than 40 goals in a season and has kicked 22 goals in just 11 games this season, Bennell has hardly played a senior game in 4 years and has no form line. For some reason the goal kicking and durable Jenkins is seen as a risk, Bennell who is battling constant injury concerns and has had many off field distractions is seen as an almost must have opportunity. Jenkins shouldn't been anywhere near the VU Whitten Oval but Bennell should be...I don't get the logic. Lumbering or not, Jenkins plays deep and I don't think he's been exposed in that area.
And to top it off the jury is apparently still out on Dale after one game.
I'm not sure we need Jenkins but I don't share the view that he shouldn't be anywhere near the club based on what I've seen.
Bennell might be a good news story but based on form it's more of a risk
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GVGjr
I don't get your selection criteria. Jenkins has has often kicked more than 40 goals in a season and has kicked 22 goals in just 11 games this season, Bennell has hardly played a senior game in 4 years and has no form line. For some reason the goal kicking and durable Jenkins is seen as a risk, Bennell who is battling constant injury concerns and has had many off field distractions is seen as an almost must have opportunity. Jenkins shouldn't been anywhere near the VU Whitten Oval but Bennell should be...I don't get the logic. Lumbering or not, Jenkins plays deep and I don't think he's been exposed in that area.
And to top it off the jury is apparently still out on Dale after one game.
I'm not sure we need Jenkins but I don't share the view that he shouldn't be anywhere near the club based on what I've seen.
Bennell might be a good news story but based on form it's more of a risk
I have stated my reasons and they are different to yours.
Jury out because Dale, every year plays one or two good games and then disappears. I want him to be consistent every week, and contribute.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GVGjr
I don't get your selection criteria. Jenkins has has often kicked more than 40 goals in a season and has kicked 22 goals in just 11 games this season, Bennell has hardly played a senior game in 4 years and has no form line. For some reason the goal kicking and durable Jenkins is seen as a risk, Bennell who is battling constant injury concerns and has had many off field distractions is seen as an almost must have opportunity. Jenkins shouldn't been anywhere near the VU Whitten Oval but Bennell should be...I don't get the logic. Lumbering or not, Jenkins plays deep and I don't think he's been exposed in that area.
And to top it off the jury is apparently still out on Dale after one game.
I'm not sure we need Jenkins but I don't share the view that he shouldn't be anywhere near the club based on what I've seen.
Bennell might be a good news story but based on form it's more of a risk
I think it's pretty simple. Jenkins will cost a shite load and unless we're sending Naughton back full time (which I don't want to do) , BAD is right in that it pretty much means Schache or Trengove have to go. Jenkins' ceiling is low and he has more stinkers than solid games. Bennell is a bigger risk but you'd think would be prepared to prove himself for unders. If it works the sky is the limit. We're crying out for a skillful, quick outside goalkicker not a washed up never been who is going to take the spot of one of our developing talls.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
But age is being offered up as the reason and that he is supposedly lumbering. I'm not sure we need him but compared to Bennell he seems like less of a risk
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
I don't want either of them but I can understand the rationale behind our supposed interest in Bennell re. potential skill set. FWIW we have the cash and I'd prefer to go for a bone fide smart small like Martin or Tippa. Maybe Bennell is plan C but I don't get the Jenkins discussion. He's behind our current two tall forwards at the moment at least as far as I'm concerned.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
we were all over Martin in his draft year, was high on our list of players we deeply considered
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Throughandthrough
we were all over Martin in his draft year, was high on our list of players we deeply considered
We were looking at giving up the Ward pick for him IIRC, which probably means no Macrae. Sometimes we really are saved from ourselves.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
No the word is lumbering.
Jury still out on Dale. He was playing shocking footy and had been on the list for 7 years. Saved himself With a couple of good games but needs to back it up.
On Harley, yes I would give a potential A grader a go
Honestly? If Dustin Martin says he's too loose. That's saying something.
Club's no dickhead's policy seems to be going well. No thanks.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
No way to Bennell
Potential a grader, but no for me
No to Jenkins also , as we have Schache developing nicely now
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
On Harley, yes I would give a potential A grader a go
With your dislike of Stringer I'm surprised you'd want Harley anywhere near our list.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Given Bennell tried to fight a journo at the Brownlow you'd have to think Bevo would be a fan.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Heard on the radio that one Victorian club has contacted Bennell's management. Hawthorn would be my guess.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
chef
With your dislike of Stringer I'm surprised you'd want Harley anywhere near our list.
Completely different
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bornadog
Completely different
Agree, Bennell is next level DH compared to Jake.
Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
chef
Agree, Bennell is next level DH compared to Jake.
I have more sympathy for someone brought up under his circumstances. No one wanted Sydney Stack and he has been turned around.
Jake well, besides his off field behavior which was lower than low, he is actually a very ordinary footballer, who has potential, but he is too lazy to work hard. 7 disposals last night proved that.