Search:

Type: Posts; User: The Pie Man; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 74 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.19 seconds.

  1. Re: Always Right Match Committee Rnd 10, vs North Melbourne

    Didn’t see Cordy rucking ...or us winning 4 clearances in a row and finding English on the lead in two of those phases.

    Weird game - and of course mjp raised valid concerns, the forum’s worth...
  2. Re: Always Right Match Committee Rnd 10, vs North Melbourne

    But do we though?

    We’ve gone deliberately small before to force our mids to lower their eyes. Some of our better games were with Picken & Dickson kicking the bulk of our score.

    My/The changes...
  3. Re: Always Right Match Committee Rnd 10, vs North Melbourne

    Itís a new philosophy, one where we take The Pie Manís suggested changes from WOOF and just run with those.

    ....Iíll show myself out
  4. Thread: War chest.

    by The Pie Man
    Replies
    51
    Views
    994

    Re: War chest.

    Cheaper option also from Sydney might be Ben Ronke?

    Would anyone be keen on Jack Higgins? Believe we would've picked him if Ed Richards had been taken.
  5. Thread: War chest.

    by The Pie Man
    Replies
    51
    Views
    994

    Re: War chest.

    I like Papley - was promoted into their leadership group this year so not sure if that's a good sign they'd be keen to release.

    Sydney can turn things around pretty quickly too I reckon.

    We'd...
  6. Re: Always Right Match Committee Rnd 10, vs North Melbourne

    I like Gowers - but most times he got an opportunity last weekend 1 on 1 he gave away a stupid free kick.

    Billy's talented, but I believe he needs some time at Footscray to find the footy again....
  7. Re: Always Right Match Committee Rnd 10, vs North Melbourne

    Didn't sound like Tim was going to be available this week either.

    Lewis Young or even Sweet should play if English isn't fit.
  8. Replies
    22
    Views
    376

    Re: New Indigenous jumper

    Just took a peak at North's effort - looks good.....but there's going to be a lot of blue on Saturday.
  9. Re: Always Right Match Committee Rnd 10, vs North Melbourne

    In : Williams, Dale, English, Lipinski
    Out : Young, Gowers, Roberts, Hayes
  10. Replies
    263
    Views
    1,915

    Re: WB Game Day V Geelong R9 2019

    Think Young has a future though - the other 3 I’m not so sure
  11. Replies
    263
    Views
    1,915

    Re: WB Game Day V Geelong R9 2019

    Gowers seriously - two reasonable forward chances squandered, costing us big time
  12. Replies
    263
    Views
    1,915

    Re: WB Game Day V Geelong R9 2019

    If you go to handball and itís knocked loose / smothered in the tackle, that has to be holding the ball doesnít it?
  13. Replies
    263
    Views
    1,915

    Re: WB Game Day V Geelong R9 2019

    Lachie’s been reading my posts - his disposal has been mint today
  14. Replies
    24
    Views
    401

    Re: Does anyone think we can beat Geelong?

    Was down there in 2017, we should’ve won that night.

    Hawkins with Roberts worries me, but who knows. Expecting a good fight from us
  15. Replies
    164
    Views
    3,624

    Re: Tom Boyd Retires

    Danny McGinlay said he spoke to Boyd about that moment and Tom revealled he had no idea Toby was even there!

    :D
  16. Replies
    21
    Views
    372

    Re: Can we all buy into this?

    Will indulge for this thread post only (and maybe a conversation over a beer with mates) as have avoided almost all AFL related media for a while now, and I can highly recommend.

    You feel a...
  17. Replies
    164
    Views
    3,624

    Re: Tom Boyd Retires

    I wish he hadn't done this and went on to enjoy a long, stellar career...but this does add to the enigma.

    Will be saying 'how about Tom Boyd?' in 20 - 30 years.

    Thanks Tom, be well.
  18. Re: Three things I have learned. Round 8-Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane Lions Mars Stadium

    I said I'd like to try someone like Lipinski in his role as he's a better kick - that may have sounded like I'd drop him....I wouldn't.

    And to be fair to Lachie, he's been better the past 2 games...
  19. Re: Always Right Match Committee Thread Rd 8, Vs Brisbane Lions

    Maybe Libba needs a rest

    Agree Suckling plays if fit.
  20. Re: Is Bevo Under Pressure to Perform this Year?

    Was an interesting response - from memory he was referring to Naughton. I wondered what criticism he had in mind...has anyone in the media pushed that barrow?
  21. Replies
    255
    Views
    2,943

    Re: WB Game Day V Richmond R7 2019

    Great tackle Hunter
  22. Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

    If I stand back and review my opinion of Hunter, it is a bit similar to some posters views on Suckling....I get the 10 coaches votes and B&F last year....I just feel like I'm watching a different...
  23. Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

    Yup mucked up the Suckling call

    I know Hunter is routinely named in our best...I’m just sick of the dodgy disposal & at times questionable effort at the contest. Lippa has a tank (not sure if it’s...
  24. Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

    It’s either Trengove, Lewis Young or Roberts for Lynch, so it’s likely Jackson.

    Suckling a likely inclusion would see Lachie Young make way - he looks a player though

    Dale for Gowers would have...
  25. Replies
    443
    Views
    3,569

    Re: WB Game Day V Fremantle R6 2019

    Thought Ed Richards was held onto badly from that last clearance - canít understand how that doesnít get paid
  26. Replies
    443
    Views
    3,569

    Re: WB Game Day V Fremantle R6 2019

    A few have pointed out Macrae’s turnovers - how bad was Lloyd’s kick to Naughton?

    Gee we’re ordinary at times
  27. Re: Memorable wins when the dogs have been in a trough

    This thread can always trigger things both good & bad.

    Hi 1997 ...we lost 4 straight R 15-19 then beat a poor Dees at Carlton that convinced no one we were back, with a trip to AAMI the following...
  28. Re: Memorable wins when the dogs have been in a trough

    Yes! Still remember Darcy tying the scores with a long set shot, felt good to see that win after the previous 2 years (still haven’t beaten them in a final - and credit to their fans, they travel &...
  29. Re: Memorable wins when the dogs have been in a trough

    2004 was a dirty year - coming into round 12 vs St Kilda we were 3-8 (finished 5-17)

    Don’t know how we pulled that off - Bubba kicked 4!...but we managed to knock off the high flying Saints in one...
  30. Re: Always Right Match Committee R6, Vs Fremantle

    Itís truly baffling. Can only assume it was being worked on early 2017 when he was in the team and they hadnít considered his exit from the senior side was going to be more or less permanent.
    ...
  31. Re: Always Right Match Committee R6, Vs Fremantle

    Dixon kicked 5 in Fletch’s last game, and I remember Taylor Walker (and not for the first time) embarrassing him for strength & speed in Adelaide 2017.

    I’m thankful for his prelim/GF fortnight...
  32. Replies
    61
    Views
    1,349

    Re: Selection? What a cop out!!!

    This sentence sums it up for me.

    Might be a long bow to suggest selection/positioning has an effect on attitude / performance but they certainly played like it did. Yes, the mids got smashed & we...
  33. Re: 3 or more things we already know, but no one will do anything about.

    I’m finding some relevance in discussing past achievements, as it may buy a senior coach more time than perhaps is warranted
  34. Re: 3 or more things we already know, but no one will do anything about.

    I’m not in the fluke camp - but you can mount a case.

    You don’t fluke 4 finals?

    Well, West Coast underestimated us and were ripe for the upsetting
    The 2016 Hawthorn was finished, had dipped...
  35. Replies
    335
    Views
    3,754

    Re: WB Game Day V Carlton R5 2019

    I don’t share the ‘it was a fluke’ view, but not for the first time am left wondering how the hell did we pull it off?

    We’ve been largely diabolical ever since.
  36. Replies
    740
    Views
    46,769

    Re: Damien Barrett what's his agenda ?

    Decent little patch by the Saints, stiff not to be unbeaten...Damo though thinks it’s time to run over Hannebery’s recruitment again.

    Borrowing a line I saw on Twitter - the game is genuinely...
  37. Re: Always Right Match Committee Thread Round 5, Vs Carlton

    So we’re doing a Lukas Webb to him - guessing we won’t see Lippa until the 2nd half of the year
  38. Re: Always Right Match Committee Thread Round 5, Vs Carlton

    No Trengove - amongst some really weird sides named in the last 4 years, this ranks as possibly the weirdest
  39. Re: Always Right Match Committee Thread Round 5, Vs Carlton

    Believe so - if Trengove comes in, it’s one of Lloyd or Smith out
  40. Re: Always Right Match Committee Thread Round 5, Vs Carlton

    Think Brad Lynch might be ready - our forward line is crying out for some pace and creativity
    With Libba back, I'm not sure Dunkley is first choice. Put McLean in the middle, Wallis forward with...
Results 1 to 40 of 2951
Page 1 of 74 1 2 3 4