Trade talk: club-by-club analysis

[azabob]

According to Emma Quayle he is uncontracted.

Interesting, wonder if he will walk then?

[G-Mo77]

I think when Eade left Hill seem to play with more enthusiasm so change of coach might be exactly what changes his career around, i hope so.

Did you watch him play in the VFL Grand Final? I thought the same thing as you up until then until I realised this is the same Josh Hill.

Look if we can keep him on the cheap and see how he goes then why not but if there is a pick there that we could use I'd rather grab that.

[ledge]

Interesting, wonder if he will walk then?

All depends if he wants to go to a club of choice or take a gamble.

[Topdog]

Hill will be good for the first month next year. Then he will stop trying again.

[azabob]

Hill will be good for the first month next year. Then he will stop trying again.

Likely. I just don't understand why doesn't want to work hard.

[G-Mo77]

Likely. I just don't understand why doesn't want to work hard.

He just doesn't have it mentally. Maybe a new coach can turn it around, I'm more than happy to give him a chance to do it but would prefer he's traded out for a pick we can use in the draft.

[LostDoggy]

Will Brisbane wave Pick 12 at the crows for Tippett? Would they budge or want much more?

Tippett and Clark worth the same? Theyve both played almost exact amount of games but Clark has been around longer. What would you do if you were the Adelaide recruiting manager, being offered pick 12? Surely you would have to push for more? Both 8 and 12?

[anfo27]

Will Brisbane wave Pick 12 at the crows for Tippett? Would they budge or want much more?

Tippett and Clark worth the same? Theyve both played almost exact amount of games but Clark has around longer. What would you do if you were the Adelaide recruiting manager, being offered pick 12? Surely you would have to push for more? Both 8 and 12?

I would take Clark over Tippett any day and if the Lions give up both picks for a player who has gone backwards for the last 2 years then Voss just hasn't learnt his lesson the first time.