It's time we had a Ling, Baker etc

[Sockeye Salmon]

Could the development (or otherwise) of O'Shea release Morris from the backline?

If nothing else, you'd hope that some mix of Harris, McDougall, Williams and maybe Everitt may release Morris and Hargrave from play on blokes half a foot taller than them.

O'Shea is a different type of player to Morris, so no, but I don't think it would be necessary anyway.

Hargrave is very quick and has a good record on smaller players and could play on the quicker types.

Harris, Mcdougall and Williams on the bigger guys, Everitt on mediums and Gilbee and Hargrave on smalls. Addison, Wight and even Murphy as injury coverage.

I'm happy with how our backline is shaping up. I also think our rucks/midfield isn't as bad as is being made out.

Our forward line is a shambles.

[DOG GOD]

both morris and hahn need to spend more time in the midfield.

[LostDoggy]

I have always thought that a tagger needs to be very strong mentally, that for me means either Morris or Boyd.
I was optimistic about Power, but when he got toweled up in the last 2 games (especially against Hodge) I was less enthused.
On the other hand if Rocket thinks he can be useful, they will probably put some time into him during the off season to get his head around it a bit.

[Dry Rot]

Welcome BB.

I suspect that we have a shortage of mentally tough guys.

[Mofra]

DFA's attack on the footy means he is an obvious choice.

Boydy is perhaps too much of a ball winner in his own right now to be a lock down player - run with yes, lock down no.

Power's problem is other coaches know he gets nervous near goal, so often dragging him into the backline works against him. Against a midfielder like Harvey (as great as he is) who is not a known goal kicker, he can do ok. Against a midfielder/forward (ala Hodge, Cooney, Ablett, Chapman etc) he will get carved up.

D-Mac has run with quicker players, but looks more of a BP type to me, even if he kicks on afther this pre-season.

Gia did ok in a tagging role, but is nowhere near the prick he needs to be to do it every week. Perhaps the guys can prank him all summer and "mentally attune" him to the role?

[LostDoggy]

Welcome BB.

I suspect that we have a shortage of mentally tough guys.

Thanks DR, recently started looking at this forum as an alternative to BF, finally decided to take the plunge tonight....

[The Coon Dog]

Thanks DR, recently started looking at this forum as an alternative to BF, finally decided to take the plunge tonight....

You're not the first to do that & if BF continues in a similar vein you certainly wont be the last. Welcome aboard too.

[Bulldog Revolution]

I have seen Morris run into the midfield as part of his lock down role and he was a non factor.
In short I'd prefer to see a tagger who can win the ball on their own merit as well and I don't think Morris can do that. Around the ground he might be OK but really I think he is a defender.

You might be right, Morris probably hasn't won enough of it when in the midfield. But then every backline needs a guy like him who loves a challenge and wants to play on Pavlich, Riewoldt etc. Dale has now played 60 odd games and is only 25 so its not inconcievable that he may make another big leap forward in 2008. The great thing about Dale is that you just know he will be doing everything he can to make it happen.

[Bulldog Revolution]

Its been mentioned elsewhere but I was surprised that Simon Godfrey had been delisted

Do people think he would be a useful addition?

or are his skills just too bad to negate any positive impact?

[southerncross]

Its been mentioned elsewhere but I was surprised that Simon Godfrey had been delisted

Do people think he would be a useful addition?

or are his skills just too bad to negate any positive impact?

I'm not a fan but I was surprised that they delisted him. My idea of an effective run with player is someone who can win enough of the ball himself but still being very accountable for his opponent. Just being a stopper isn't enough.

[Bulldog Revolution]

I'm not a fan but I was surprised that they delisted him. My idea of an effective run with player is someone who can win enough of the ball himself but still being very accountable for his opponent. Just being a stopper isn't enough.

So SC you believe he is too defensive for modern footy?

I thought this article was interesting

Ward sings Godfrey's praises
16 September 2007 Sunday Herald Sun
Jon Ralph

DUMPED Melbourne onballer Daniel Ward says rival clubs looking for a lock-down tagger would be crazy not to look at Simon Godfrey, also discarded this week by new coach Dean Bailey.

Ward and Godfrey were let go by Bailey on Monday, joining retirees Clint Bizzell, Byron Pickett and Nathan Brown in a player exodus.

Ward, 30, who overcame much-publicised gambling problems earlier this year, yesterday thanked the Demons for his time at the club and said he felt no bitterness.

But he wasted no time in spruiking the wares of 26-year-old Godfrey.

"I knew I was in a bit of trouble -- 30 and out of contract with a new coach," Ward said.

"I was prepared for the worst and got the worst. I gave my pitch and at the end of it, (Dean) said, 'There is not a spot on the list for you'.

"He was great. The way he handled it, I have no qualms at all. The club has been great for me.

"I am a little bit disappointed for 'Godders' more than me, and hopefully he gets picked up and gets another opportunity.

"The club said he wasn't the right fit going forward, but if there is any club out there that wants a guy who can shut down the opposition's best player every week and give his heart and soul to the footy club, Simon Godfrey is that guy."

Godfrey played 17 of the first 18 games this year, containing the likes of Shane Crawford, Chris Judd, Daniel Kerr and Adam Goodes.

"If I was on a coaching staff I would be looking very, very closely at Simon Godfrey, that's for sure," Ward said.

"If they want references, they can ring blokes like (Scott) West, blokes he has shut down. He is a great guy to have around the club and his teammates love playing with him.

"If we had 22 Simon Godfreys in the side each week this year we wouldn't have lost a game."

[Sockeye Salmon]

"If we had 22 Simon Godfreys in the side each week this year we wouldn't have lost a game."

If you had 22 Simon Godfrey's in your side they would have to re-write the records for turnovers.

[Sedat]

Even the best lock-down players manage to find the footy themselves. Rawlings and Ling are great examples of what the modern tagger's role should now incorporate. Godfrey's way is the Libba way, and it doesn't work in today's game.

Plus, as Sockeye alluded to, he is a butcher of the ball par excellence.

[Dry Rot]

Any other candidates out there who may not be getting a good run with their current side?

[Go_Dogs]

I've been harping on about his name all year, Nick Lower. His brother Ed did a good job on Sam Mitchell second half last week - held him to 8 touches and 1 clearance.