Something I have been concerned about for a while with our style of play is the way our forwards run away from space leaving the midfield open for us to run into. I recall track watchers referring to our guys using the term "take the space" and I think in general is they want the ball carrier to run with the ball into space and draw players which I suppose is designed to cover our lack of tall forwards. I have watched closely this season and when we have the ball at say half back our forwards will not lead up the ground at the ball carrier to create the link and they will instead hold off and keep that space free for our runners to run and draw their way forward or they will even lead away from the guy with the ball to the point where they are almost 2 kicks away from the guy with the ball.
We first started doing this in early 2006 when we took Rob Murphy away from CHF and started playing him deeper and I think then when we lost him to injury it became more ingrained into our style of play. We have all stressed the need for us to have a lead up centre half forward but unless we change this philosophy then it would be pointless to bring someone in to play this role. My mates and I watched all year space open up for our guys to lead up the ground and they just would not take it and I can only believe based on that and what has been said by track watchers that it is a pre concieved idea and not poor decision making by the players.
The problem I have with it is that teams have learnt to either stand off us and make us kick over them or they are zoning up the midfield ala crows and the hawks and making it impossible for us to run and draw our way through. When they stand off us we dont get the run and carry needed to give our forwards a chance because the opposition wont run at us and give us an overlap and when they flood the midfield we turn the ball over when we have massive numbers running forward in waves and then get caught on the rebound.
Unless we fundamentally change this style of play then I dont think Murphy or anyone else is going to get a kick playing as a CHF. With the two major trade rumours being Robertson who can play out at half forward or deep and McGregor who can also do both I am hoping that Eade may be looking at changing this plan and I think we will find Murphy and these types all of a sudden become more invlvoved again.
Not sure if anyone else agrees with all of this. Just something I have kept an eye for most of the year. I think it may well be half of the problem.