Does having a gun pointed at your head count
One Jade Rawlings
One would have to question a players head space if he was somewhere he didn't want to be. Sure they would play football but is their heart in it.
I would never bother with a player if he stated he didn't want to be at your club, I would focus our energy on some one who did.
Don't piss off old people
The older we get the less "LIFE IN PRISON" is a deterrent...
Oh I'm not really comparing I'm just noting a historical trajectory from my point of view. I was a young broken hearted kid when these guys left. Just feels like no one of the Dempsey, Quinlan calibre have ever come to our club just prior to them coming into their prime. Other clubs always seem to do better from our outs. (other than perhaps Richmond with Judas et al). Yes we delisted Hawk, even worse IMO, shameful really.
Both at the very ends of their careers, Hall was good for us no doubt and Aker was serviceable but it was really a short term leg up. It's different.
But then again, I'm an Internet poster and Bevo is a premiership coach so draw your own conclusions.
But then again, I'm an Internet poster and Bevo is a premiership coach so draw your own conclusions.
Pretty big fish who were at the tail end of their careers and who both came with significant risks attached.
When is the last time we've attracted a big name to our club who is under 30 or hasn't come with a sizeable risk attached? When have we ever?
We are delusional if we think we are a chance to snare a big name.
Best we can hope for is a yet to prove himself youngster, fringe, role or fading veteran type
When was the last time we were after one of these types, especially since Jade Rawlings scared us off that kind of quick fix?
For all their brovado and money who have Collingwood lured away in the modern era?
A very good but aging Ruckman and a slow mid on one leg, not exactly Buddy or Jono Brown. Yes they were both good players but Ball was on the fringes of St Kilda and Jolly was a star but only had a couple of years left in him as we are seeing now. How is that any different to what we normally get?
Not inferiority nor negativity, reality.
Just because I am not asking if we are a chance to land Tippett, or if we are going to go hard for Caddy or as per some earlier in the year, should we throw the bank at Cloke does not make me negative.
I am just acknowledging the reality, that we are for whatever reason not seen as a destination of choice for high profile players seeking to find a new club.
I don't like it one little bit mind you. It makes me sick to the stomach that even during our recent successful times that we are never seriously in the hunt for a marquee player. And that the only way in recent times we were able to secure someone of relative profile was due to skullduggery and manipulation - when we landed Rawlings.
It makes me frustrated that a Mitch Clark would choose a Melbourne over us, or that whenever a decent player in his prime is looking for a new club, we are NEVER that player's club of choice.
I tell you what though it is getting a little worrying that if anything but the peachy keen positivity view point is presented here, people get shot down and personally accused of having an inferiority complex.