I didn't see enough of Hawk at his peak, but from the players I did see I'd take Chris Grant any day of the week. He kicked over 550 goals having played about half his career in defence, and for mine is the most underrated player of the 90's.
With that in mind I struggle to fathom how good Hawk must have been, and how underrated he seemingly is by non-Bulldogs people.
Alas, the problem our players have post career in terms of recognition. If they had the benefit of premiership medals hanging around their necks it probably wouldn't matter to them much, even though they'd be immeasurably more revered outside our club as a result of it.