Pack your bags McCartney...

[westdog54]

Interesting you say that.

I tried to PM you recently and it got rejected as your inbox was full. I then addressed you directly on the forum about it and you didn't bother to respond.

I don't really care about your moderating or anyone else's for that matter - but if you're expected to act as some kind of moral arbiter then I think it's fair to expect some restraint.

I sympathise with being unhappy about it. I am too. But let's focus our ire where it belongs and not on those who just have different ideas to us.

My inbox is not full. I'll speak to GVG, may be a technical glitch.

As for your idea that I didn't respond, I think you'll find I replied to your post.

I'll say no more on the matter.

[EasternWest]

My inbox is not full. I'll speak to GVG, may be a technical glitch.

As for your idea that I didn't respond, I think you'll find I replied to your post.

I'll say no more on the matter.

Since switching to the new format I can't go far enough back in my post history to verify that. If you're able to point it out I'd appreciate that as I'd still like to know what you replied.

[hujsh]

If this is to satisfy cozy senior players then it's no good. If young players like Dahl were seriously looking at leaving because of Macca then he probably had to go.

[BulldogBelle]

If this is to satisfy cozy senior players then it's no good. If young players like Dahl were seriously looking at leaving because of Macca then he probably had to go.

l think this a very relevant point. If the young players started to complain he had to go. But will we ever really know?

[LostDoggy]

l think this a very relevant point. If the young players started to complain he had to go. But will we ever really know?

I think we have a right to know what happened. After all we are the members, this is as much our club as any player coach or administrator.

[Daughter of the West]

If this is to satisfy cozy senior players then it's no good. If young players like Dahl were seriously looking at leaving because of Macca then he probably had to go.

I agree with this line of thinking completely, but the way this has all been executed - from Griff to the board to Macca - has been a debacle of the highest order. THE highest order. We currently look like a bunch of tail chasing numpties.

[bornadog]

I agree with this line of thinking completely, but the way this has all been executed - from Griff to the board to Macca - has been a debacle of the highest order. THE highest order. We currently look like a bunch of tail chasing numpties.

so nothing has changed in 130 years of existence

[bulldogtragic]

I guess the thread poster was right, just 17 months early. As a principle of equity, Garry Lyon was smashed by Melbourne people for the Neeld selection. Some scrutiny of those who appointed the now failed/sacked need some attention, especially if they want to do it again.