RE Lake - Once a player starts talking about going or hinting they want out surely the club should look to trade them out.
What is debatable is did we get a good deal for him?
By posters looking at the Hrovat trade in isolation perhaps we didn't get enough for him, but I'm sure the club did not just look at the trade in isolation, they would have looked beyond 2013, they would've looked to 2015 and beyond.
They would've taken into account by trading Lake give's us 3 top 20 picks and by all accounts all 3 players we drafted look like they will play a lot of senior football for our club and the draft overall for us looks very promising.
They would've looked at if Lake stayed and left at the end of 2013, what would we get for him? Is the draft as strong this in 2013 or 2014?
His salary, can we spend the money on a free agent or on a 25 year old who will help our "age profile"?
Would Lake have changed the course of our year? Would we win 8 games instead of 7?
Brian Lake was a champion for our football club, no doubt, but he would not have improved our ladder position this year or next.
He would've have taken Tom Campbells spot in the forward line or Michael Talia's in the backline.
I am comfortable we bit the bullet and traded Lake, and I am also comfortable that Lake showed he is a big game player, just like he did when he played with us.