The Moving Rolling De-Listing/Trading Thread 2016

[ledge]

Being a premiership side our players automatically are over rated , especially fringe players . Whoever goes mark my words whoever comes in will be better . They will have to offer overs.

[I'm Not Bitter Anymore!]

Bugger

[Remi Moses]

Disappointing to be honest . Need to keep Adams and look at someone else as a trade .

[Hotdog60]

Freo has got bugger all to offer, do we try and steal Collins to cover Adams after next year.

[GVGjr]

peter ryan ‏@petryan 5m5 minutes ago
.@westernbulldogs defender Joel Hamling has decided to join Fremantle. #AFLTrades

Not surprising. Now lets get a deal done.

Lets aim for pick 35 from Fremantle. Surely an athletic key defender who has GF experience with an impressive shut down of Buddy Franklin is more important to them than a 3rd string key forward in Kersten.

[GVGjr]

Freo has got bugger all to offer, do we try and steal Collins to cover Adams after next year.

Sam Collins?

[azabob]

Funny how the cookie crumbles.

Half time at Kadina Park in round 17, his papers seemed stamped. Moved from CHF to FB and doesn't miss a beat from then on.

I think he is a bigger loss than Adams will be.

I hope Hamling is prepared for what is instore at Freo. No team defense, and last time I checked Ross Lyon was more about tough love than put your arm around you love.

[jeemak]

Does Hayden Crozier hold any interest as a straight swap?

[Topdog]

No team defence in a Ross Lyon coached side??

[Sedat]

Future 1st rounder for Hamling? Or is that reaching beyond reality?

[GVGjr]

Here is a crazy scenario that all hinges on if Fremantle rates Hamling more than Kersten and they should.

Hrovat to North for their 2nd round pick #33.
Hamling to Fremantle for their 2nd round pick #35.
Adams to West Coast for their 2nd round pick #34.
Our 2nd round pick #34 (acquired from West Coast) our 2nd round pick #40 to Port for Jackson Trengove and their 3rd round pick #49
Our 3rd round pick #49 (acquired from Port) to Collingwood for Travis Cloke

We have picks #18 in the 1st round and picks #33 and #34 in the 2nd round and we still have a Kobe Stens trade to complete.

Essentially we have to weigh up if losing WA bound Hamling and Adams (potentially end of next season) now for Trengove and Cloke now is a decent return?

If that went through it would look something like this:

In for the 2017 season: Crameri from the 2016 suspension, Trengove from Port, Cloke from Collingwood and 3 draftees from 2016 draft picks #18, #33 and #34 and something from Kobe Stevens trade

Out from the 2016 season, Minson, Prudden, Hrovat, Hamling, Stevens and Adams.

[Hotdog60]

Sam Collins?

Yeah Sam Collins from Box Hill. Not as mature as Adams but has played some games this year.
2016 Season Average
Collins:
Games Played 12
Kicks 7.4; Handballs 5.7; Disposals 13.1; Marks 5.2; Hit-Outs 0.8; Tackles 2.6
Adams:
2016 Season Average
Games Played 11
Kicks 8.6; Handballs 7.6; Disposals 16.3; Marks 5.7; Hit-Outs 0.0; Tackles 2.3

[The Bulldogs Bite]

It's been a shit week for the club after an almighty high.

Very disappointed in Hamling.

[Doc26]

Here is a crazy scenario that all hinges on if Fremantle rates Hamling more than Kersten and they should.

Hrovat to North for their 2nd round pick #33.
Hamling to Fremantle for their 2nd round pick #35.
Adams to West Coast for their 2nd round pick #34.
Our 2nd round pick #34 (acquired from West Coast) our 2nd round pick #40 to Port for Jackson Trengove and their 3rd round pick #49
Our 3rd round pick #49 (acquired from Port) to Collingwood for Travis Cloke

We have picks #18 in the 1st round and picks #33 and #34 in the 2nd round

Essentially we have to weigh up if losing WA bound Hamling and Adams (potentially end of next season) now for Trengove and Cloke now is a decent return?

If that went through it would look something like this:

In for the 2017 season: Crameri from the 2016 suspension, Trengove from Port, Cloke from Collingwood and 3 draftees from 2016 draft picks #18, #33 and #34.
Out from the 2016 season, Minson, Prudden, Hrovat, Hamling and Adams.

Where have any murmurings for Trengove moving from Port come from ? Is he unhappy ? Does Port have interest in offloading him ? Or is this coming from speculation that their salary cap is at some breaking point ?

[GVGjr]

Yeah Sam Collins from Box Hill. Not as mature as Adams but has played some games this year.
2016 Season Average
Collins:
Games Played 12
Kicks 7.4; Handballs 5.7; Disposals 13.1; Marks 5.2; Hit-Outs 0.8; Tackles 2.6
Adams:
2016 Season Average
Games Played 11
Kicks 8.6; Handballs 7.6; Disposals 16.3; Marks 5.7; Hit-Outs 0.0; Tackles 2.3

I don't mind him but given Fremantle is not interested in Adams so I think the comparison should be with Hamling.