Match Committee - Round 21, 2017 vs GWS Giants

[MrMahatma]

In: Stringer, JJ, Roberts, Dickson
Out: Wood, Smith, Webb, Murph

[Mantis]

In: Stringer, JJ, Roberts, Dickson
Out: Wood, Smith, Webb, Murph

That looks about right, but in picking Roberts I have absolutely no confidence that he will be able to look after Patton or Lobb... He has looked all at sea this year.

[azabob]

That looks about right, but in picking Roberts I have absolutely no confidence that he will be able to look after Patton or Lobb... He has looked all at sea this year.

There is only Roberts & Collins left though.

[Axe Man]

Going by the history of the match committee I would be very surprised if we picked 3 tall defenders to play against Patton and Lobb. They are probably more likely to only play 1 KPD than 3 of them!

[hujsh]

Will Lobb even be playing forward or will they use him to replace Mumford?

[Mantis]

Will Lobb even be playing forward or will they use him to replace Mumford?

Would think they bring in Dawson Simpson.

[Happy Days]

Would think they bring in Dawson Simpson.

Nice.

[merantau]

With Mumford out they have a big problem . For a big bloke he actually gets to a lot more contests than you would expect so they will miss him around the ground and we can cash in here big time Dawson Simpson - come on down!

Cloke and Redpath must play. Roberts or Collins in for Wood

[Eastdog]

I'll have crack subject to change:

In: JJ, Stringer, Dickson, Collins

Out: Wood, Webb, Smith, Murph

[Eastdog]

There is only Roberts & Collins left though.

You would probably go Roberts but be good to see how Collins goes at AFL Level a bit more so I have selected him. Hopefully Marcus Adams isn't too far away. Was very good until the injury.

[Bulldog4life]

Bevo said that Murph pulled up better after the game than the game before

[Eastdog]

Bevo said that Murph pulled up better after the game than the game before

In that case maybe someone else might go out for Murphy to retain his spot.

[merantau]

Bob must play. This is the most important game of the year. Cloke and Redpath must play. JJ if fit must play, also Stringer. And what about M. Boyd? How about sending him out to do a number on Toby Green? A close checking, harrassing role, punctuated with some crunching tackles is a role he would enjoy, I think.

[Rocco Jones]

Matthew Boyd is struggling with his achilles again, so he won't be in.

In- JJ, Stringer, Dickson or Dunkley if he isn't right
Out- Wood, Clay, Webb

Just don't trust Fletch at the moment/not the right game to bring in Collins and would rather go with a more mobile team defence.

[ledge]

I would love to see Clay on Toby Greene , bet he doesn't mouth off and give cheap shots with Clay smashing him at every opportunity.