Stringer Trade Worth

[Doc26]

That would be perfect, pick 4 plus Goldy. North ain't going no where either. for a few years.

It's fair to assume that North were already planning on giving up pick 4 for either Dusty or Kelly. Given that neither now look likely, they may well view Stringer in a similar light to these two. The thing is, Jake's a known commoditywith star power and baggage, whereas pick 4 leaves no guarantees for an extreme talent such as Jake's, unless of course we can leverage this pick with a suitable trade.

[Twodogs]

According to this;

http://aflworld360.com/crows-dockers...r-3-way-trade/

Jesse Hogan is being valued at pick 5. Jake Stringer got to be worth the same as Jesse Hogan surely?

[Topdog]

So Lever is worth pick 5 or Hogan? That's insane

[Twodogs]

So Lever is worth pick 5 or Hogan? That's insane

I agree but it shows how wildly valuations can fluctuate.

It'll annoy me if Hogan is valued above an AA premiership player purely on Hogan's potential. Stringers potential and output are superior to Hogan. If Hogan is somehow a better player because he hasn't displayed his full potential then I give up on footy.

[chef]

I'd take Hogan in a heart beat over Stringer if I was another club choosing one. You can build your forward line around Hogan, Jake is such an unknown quantity nowadays.

[LostDoggy]

I'd take Hogan in a heart beat over Stringer if I was another club choosing one. You can build your forward line around Hogan, Jake is such an unknown quantity nowadays.

Some Melbourne supporters believe they are better without Hogan. I'd have Stringer over him. Just.

[LostDoggy]

I agree but it shows how wildly valuations can fluctuate.

It'll annoy me if Hogan is valued above an AA premiership player purely on Hogan's potential. Stringers potential and output are superior to Hogan. If Hogan is somehow a better player because he hasn't displayed his full potential then I give up on footy.

Yep that would annoy me too.

[bulldogtragic]

I'd take Hogan in a heart beat over Stringer if I was another club choosing one. You can build your forward line around Hogan, Jake is such an unknown quantity nowadays.

If that was a straight swap to us for example, yep, that's sign it in a heart beat stuff.

[Topdog]

I'd take Hogan in a heart beat over Stringer if I was another club choosing one. You can build your forward line around Hogan, Jake is such an unknown quantity nowadays.

Agreed! Are people forgetting Hogan has kicked 44 and 41 goals in seasons already?

105 goals from his first 51 games is an excellent return. Actually funnily enough that is exactly what Stringer did in his first 51.

Hogan is a year younger and is a tall forward

[Rocket Science]

There is one other thing that separates Stringer & Hogan.

One of them hasn't been shown the door by his footy club.

[Bulldog4life]

There is one other thing that separates Stringer & Hogan.

One of them hasn't been shown the door by his footy club.

Yep baggage plays an important part when you are valuing a players's worth.

[Twodogs]

There is one other thing that separates Stringer & Hogan.

One of them hasn't been shown the door by his footy club.

The fact one is a premiership player and one isn't is what seperates them in my eyes. That's the really important stat. That's what we play for, that's the ultimate measure of a player.

They can say what they like about Hogan's potential. Jake has the runs on the board. Until he is a premiership player Hogan is just a blowhard compared to Stringer.

[jeemak]

The fact one is a premiership player and one isn't is what seperates them in my eyes. That's the really important stat. That's what we play for, that's the ultimate measure of a player.

They can say what they like about Hogan's potential. Jake has the runs on the board. Until he is a premiership player Hogan is just a blowhard compared to Stringer.

So Stringer is already better than Doug Hawkins and Chris Grant?

[Topdog]

The fact one is a premiership player and one isn't is what seperates them in my eyes. That's the really important stat. That's what we play for, that's the ultimate measure of a player.

They can say what they like about Hogan's potential. Jake has the runs on the board. Until he is a premiership player Hogan is just a blowhard compared to Stringer.

Sorry TD but cant agree with that at all. You could make a stance on AA selection to rate an individual but footy is a team game and premiership medals count for squat when comparing players.

[Topdog]

So Stringer is already better than Doug Hawkins and Chris Grant?

Fletcher Roberts is better than Grant too.