I'm not sure if we are interested in Schache or not but at the very least he creates some conflicting views on his value we can discuss.

The Pros:
Highly talented player
Good kick and mark
For a player that has been homesick he has still racked up 27 games in 2 seasons which is a fair bit of development
Great endurance base
Good at the ground level
Can take a spell in the ruck
Good news story if we were to trade for him
Could be a bargain

The Cons:
Will he still be homesick living in Melbourne?
Slow
Lacks aggression
Has a reputation for being lazy and having a poor work rate
Could be a bust

On paper it looks like there is more upside than downside but there is some downside that we would need to consider

So is it worth having a crack at getting him?