The Moving/Rolling Trading & Delisting Thread 2018

[divvydan]

Confirmed 2nd rd pick compensation. Dahlhaus was an unrestricted free agent, so even if we thought we could get more in a trade, we had no option to match.
Will definitely be needed for West.

[bulldogtragic]

Confirmed 2nd rd pick compensation. Dahlhaus was an unrestricted free agent, so even if we thought we could get more in a trade, we had no option to match.
Will definitely be needed for West.

So pick 25 less shuffling down? That’s still a good haul of points towards West.

[divvydan]

Yeah, currently 25, will probably end up on at least 26 (GC compo) and could change either way after earlier academy players. Probably won't be enough to get West on his own as Pick 26 is 729 points, which would allow us to cover anything after a bid at pick 20 but West is likely to be bid on a little before that.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

So pick 25 less shuffling down? That’s still a good haul of points towards West.

BT wouldn't it be more beneficial to us in trading that Pick 25 out and securing a player of need, then using later picks/points to secure West and Khamis?

Otherwise we essentially lose Dahlhaus for West which isn't great given we're always taking West regardless.

[Happy Days]

BT wouldn't it be more beneficial to us in trading that Pick 25 out and securing a player of need, then using later picks/points to secure West and Khamis?

Otherwise we essentially lose Dahlhaus for West which isn't great given we're always taking West regardless.

I thought that because we don't have a second round pick that without 25 we wouldn't be getting West.

[divvydan]

We could get West even without a 2nd round pick, however we would likely go into a points deficit and the remaining points owed would be taken off our first pick next year.

[hujsh]

I thought that because we don't have a second round pick that without 25 we wouldn't be getting West.

Nah, if we don't have the points we can go into deficit for next year.

[GVGjr]

BT wouldn't it be more beneficial to us in trading that Pick 25 out and securing a player of need, then using later picks/points to secure West and Khamis?

Otherwise we essentially lose Dahlhaus for West which isn't great given we're always taking West regardless.

I'd use the pick to acquire another player, we probably don't have the numbers in the list though

It seems to be a fair return for Dahlhaus given his refusal to accept a fair offer from us

I'm more than a bit 'motivated' by getting a 2nd round pick for him

[Topdog]

We have more father sons to get next year so can't really afford to go into a deficit

[EasternWest]

We have more father sons to get next year so can't really afford to go into a deficit

Is one of them Liberatore mk 3? Because I imagine we'd be considering that with fair circumspection now.

[bulldogtragic]

BT wouldn't it be more beneficial to us in trading that Pick 25 out and securing a player of need, then using later picks/points to secure West and Khamis?

Otherwise we essentially lose Dahlhaus for West which isn't great given we're always taking West regardless.

I’m no fan of deficits. So we could trade it, to me, in an existing trade if we can secure a net draft points trade.

I see trading it in the Wingard trade maybe if it eventuates. 7 & 27 for 29 & 47.

Then we bulk up on lower points circa 29, 44, 45 (Roughy compo?), 47, 62 & 63 to secure West & Khamis. 80 on Lloyd.

So maybe our 8 spots are: Wingard, Lloyd, Gowers, Lynch, West (1st), Khamis (2nd) and two picks (maybe Hayes, an NGA or Smiths year elevation if the pick is too low).

Then Adams, if traded, can move things around. But we need something juicy in the 20’s heading in. Deficits are no good with two potential FSs next years and then more the year after.

[bulldogtragic]

BT wouldn't it be more beneficial to us in trading that Pick 25 out and securing a player of need, then using later picks/points to secure West and Khamis?

Otherwise we essentially lose Dahlhaus for West which isn't great given we're always taking West regardless.

I’m no fan of deficits. So we could trade it, to me, in an existing trade if we can secure a net draft points trade.

I see trading it in the Wingard trade maybe if it eventuates. 7 & 27 for 29 & 47.

Then we bulk up on lower points circa 29, 44, 45 (Roughy compo?), 47, 62 & 63 to secure West & Khamis. 80 on Lloyd.

So maybe our 8 spots are: Wingard, Lloyd, Gowers, Lynch, West (1st), Khamis (2nd) and two picks (maybe Hayes, an NGA or Smiths year elevation if the pick is too low).

Then Adams, if traded, can move things around. But we need something juicy in the 20’s heading in. Deficits are no good with two potential FSs next years and then more the year after.

[mitch0418]

Is Rohan Smith's son Jacob up for draft this year? Sorry if this has been discussed before. I just haven't heard much about him and only seem to hear about Rhylee West. I thought Jacob was either the same age as Rhylee or older?

[Axe Man]

A prospective father/son list courtesy of big footy:

Eligible Father/Sons

Rhylee West - (2018 Draft)
Joshua Kellett - (2019 Draft)
Oliver Liberatore (2019 Draft)
Tyler Kolyniuk (2019 Draft)
Daniel Romero (2019 Draft)
Ewan MacPherson (2020 Draft)
Sam Darcy - (2021 Draft)
Cooper West - (2021 Draft)
Kobi West - (2021 Draft)
Kyan Eagleton - (2022 Draft)
Mitchell Croft - (2022 Draft)
Jordan Croft - (2022 Draft)
Tom Garlick - (2023 Draft)
Max Darcy - (2023 Draft)
Jack Johnson - (2023 Draft)
Harry Cameron - (2024 Draft)
Lukas Eagleton - (2025 Draft)
Jaxon Cooney - (2025 Draft)
Oliver Grant - (2025 Draft)
Jarvis Murphy - (2025 Draft)
Cohen Lake - (2025 Draft)
Sonny Garlick - (2025 Draft)
Riley Morris - (2026 Draft)
Zakaria Daniel Mark Southern (2028 Draft)
Charlie Morris (2029 Draft)
Malachy Picken - (2030 Draft)
Jack Cameron - (2030 Draft)
Levi Hahn (2030 Draft)
Otis Giansiracusa - (2030 Draft)
Tyler Cross - (2030 Draft)
Jude Brown - (2031 Draft)
Miller Kretiuk - (2034 Draft)
James Boyd - (2034 Draft)

[divvydan]

Jacob Smith was eligible a few drafts ago from what I remember. Maybe he has another younger son as well that's more Rhylee's age?