Originally Posted by
Mofra
Yep - 3 talls only works if one plays as a pseudo mid sized player (and Jenkins is overrated for mine - he's a Joe the Goose specialist and doesn't actually play that tall, just as 191cm Stringer plays much shorter than Taylor Walker).
Boyd, Schache and Redpath won't provide finals-like defensive pressure between them. The only way I can see it working is if Roughy is out and Schache/Boyd share ruck duties so there's only one of them in the forward half at any one time.
Shame Roughy is the best mark of all of them - he's the worst kick for goal in the side and perhaps the worst I've seen, although Honeychurch is a solid contender.