Apologies if this has been done before, but like most posters I did develop a completely nonsensical, irrational fondness for some players who were fringe for their entire career.

Exhibit A: Cam Wight. 200cm, amazing runner, but prone to at least one massive brainfade every game he player.

Steve Tiller - was just not quite big enough for the role he played.

Damian McCormack, showed glimpses and played quite a lot of good VFL football.