Always Right Match Committee - Round 2 vs West Coast Eagles 2021

[Before I Die]

I don't blame him.

Since the premiership -

* third man up - gone - club felt it was aimed at us
* limited use of runners
* 6.6.6
* Man on the mark
* ruck changes re prior opp
* 75 limit on rotations
* kick out man on mark 15metres from square
* injury Sub

and the VFL ones where the AFL has totally lost the plot:

Three players to be stationed inside 50 metres at each stoppage

Utter madness and not necessary

The Ruck - prior opportunity rule was aimed at us also. Darcy had dominated the ruck by taking possession rather than tapping the ball. If they had brought that in 50 years earlier, no one would have ever heard of the name Polly Farmer.

[Vred]

Nah, I think he is just focused on getting wins. I think he has the balance about right

If he was focus'd on getting wins then I want to see McNeil and Scott OUT this week and more experienced players (Wood, West) bought in, Cavarra to play sub

[whythelongface]

If he was focus'd on getting wins then I want to see McNeil and Scott OUT this week and more experienced players (Wood, West) bought in, Cavarra to play sub

Agree that McNeill and Scott should be dropped. Thought they both did some good things but would like to see Wood back in defense for this game particularly as the WC have JK, Darling and Allen. West or Cavarra are in the mix to take McNeill’s spot. But if the MC stay with McNeill I am ok with that as well.

[Cyberdoggie]

I can't see Scott getting dropped, NcNeil probably should but Bevo just about always gives new players a couple of games free ride.

It will probably be no change but if there is it would be Wood for McNeil, we may need the experience down back against 3 forwards that will give us a headache.

[bornadog]

I can't see Scott getting dropped, NcNeil probably should but Bevo just about always gives new players a couple of games free ride.

It will probably be no change but if there is it would be Wood for McNeil, we may need the experience down back against 3 forwards that will give us a headache.

Bevo has ruled Wood out for this week and maybe next.

[dog town]

McNeil is likely getting games because he is the first person to get a front and square crumb inside 50 since Dahlhaus left. It’s something we really need so they may see it as worth some pain to fast track him. Even on Friday night he got a couple of them but butchered the opportunity with a lack of composure.

[azabob]

Prefer McNeil over Cavarra by a long way.

[Grantysghost]

Prefer McNeil over Cavarra by a long way.

Agree. Not sure where the Cav love comes from he's really shown nothing at the level.
Watch McNeil's highlights in the Sanfl he's a very exciting prospect.

[EasternWest]

Agree. Not sure where the Cav love comes from he's really shown nothing at the level.
Watch McNeil's highlights in the Sanfl he's a very exciting prospect.

You would say that.

[Grantysghost]

You would say that.

[jeemak]

You would say that.

GG is definitely all in. It can't be hidden.

[Grantysghost]

GG is definitely all in. It can't be hidden.

I've gone too hard too early not sure I've got the stamina to keep this up!

[EasternWest]

GG is definitely all in. It can't be hidden.

It can be hard to tell.

Sometimes an avatar is the opposite of how you feel.

[AshMac]

McNeil is likely getting games because he is the first person to get a front and square crumb inside 50 since Dahlhaus left. It’s something we really need so they may see it as worth some pain to fast track him. Even on Friday night he got a couple of them but butchered the opportunity with a lack of composure.

Spot on. Even though he butchered them it was great to see a bloke hit the ball at pace when it came to ground and run toward our goal. Composure comes with experience - can’t learn how to be fast - think he has a decent looking base to work with.

[Happy Days]

GG is definitely all in. It can't be hidden.

GG all in? Its been done.