Always Right Match Committee - Round 8 Vs Carlton 2021

[jeemak]

I may have missed it but West not in the VFL
Med Sub?

All of Butler, Young and Marra are playing.

[Danjul]

I'm starting to wonder whether you're just trolling here?

Address the facts. why is Schache in the team if he can’t be on the ground 60% of the time.

Why did Lynch get 12 marks against us when Lynch Aand Riewoldt could not put together 12 possessions against Geelong.

No trolling.Just honest questions, which you comfortably ignore.

[Grantysghost]

Weightman, Marra and Garcia are in my future plans.

[comrade]

Address the facts. why is Schache in the team if he can’t be on the ground 60% of the time.

Why did Lynch get 12 marks against us when Lynch Aand Riewoldt could not put together 12 possessions against Geelong.

No trolling.Just honest questions, which you comfortably ignore.

Well none of that had nothing to do with Schache playing or not.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Address the facts. why is Schache in the team if he can’t be on the ground 60% of the time.

Why did Lynch get 12 marks against us when Lynch Aand Riewoldt could not put together 12 possessions against Geelong.

No trolling.Just honest questions, which you comfortably ignore.

You've comfortably ignored anything positive about our season thus far, and then surprise, surprise pop up after 1 loss to cherry pick and then try to create strawman arguments.

[Grantysghost]

Address the facts. why is Schache in the team if he can’t be on the ground 60% of the time.

Why did Lynch get 12 marks against us when Lynch Aand Riewoldt could not put together 12 possessions against Geelong.

No trolling.Just honest questions, which you comfortably ignore.

Danj...this is the most intelligent forum on Earth. I've been attacked, threatened, called insane names on other forums (reddit and bigfooty) for having for what I believe is an intelligent counter argument.
I really enjoy your counter point but no one comfortably ignores things here. Especially YHF.

I get your Schache angst, and agree it's a bit harsh to expect him to come in against an amazing side and be influential. So wanted another week.
But there are three phases of the game. When you have it, when you don't, and when it's in dispute (loose ball, stoppages). I think Josh is A grade when he has it.

My guess is the other two phases are a massive issue. It's hard to find stats to justify that, but that's what coaches have and see.

[jeemak]

It’s not rubbish, it’s a fact.

He has had less than 60% game time.

What did Hannan contribute? Nothing
What did Scott contribute? Nothing
What did Bruce contribute? Nothing (except trying to look like a clown).
What did Schache contribute? Nothing.

So how are they different? Schache spent twice as long or more on the bench.

The guy isn’t on the ground long enough to see who is around him.

last week’s loss had nothing to do with Schache. It started with the selection committee and finished with the whole team.

How did Geelong beat a stronger Richmond team by 10 goals. By being smart at selection.

What's rubbish is your comment that nobody here praises Schache. That's what I was mainly referring to.

[Happy Days]

Schache played so little because he sacked contests, just like he did last time he played and got limited game time last year, and the year before.

If a player isn't playing because of a specific and addressable weakness, and then evidence the presence of that weakness through poor application over and over again, it would be madness to keep picking them. It's totally different to the other players who "did nothing".

[HOSE B ROMERO]

Full marks to our defence for holding strong in the first half of that quarter.

[HOSE B ROMERO]

Ignore that. Wrong thread..

[Danjul]

Well none of that had nothing to do with Schache playing or not.

Exactly, it was poor team selection. Which has been ignored in the wash up of the game.

Lets focus on the important stuff and forget about the players.

[comrade]

Exactly, it was poor team selection. Which has been ignored in the wash up of the game.

Lets focus on the important stuff and forget about the players.

So was Schache a good selection or not?

[Danjul]

You've comfortably ignored anything positive about our season thus far, and then surprise, surprise pop up after 1 loss to cherry pick and then try to create strawman arguments.

Nonsense. Who said get a ruckman and was ridiculed for years? Who said move English to the forward line and was ridiculed for years?

I have been happy with the changes. I agree with most of the comments on here and have found them very informative. Nothing to add to what I think is already correct.

I am very pleased to see that we are headed for finals already.

But look at how we got to this point. We have defeated the two bottom teams. Good, I will take any win.

What happened when we met a depleted Richmond? Disaster.

That has to be addressed very quickly because it is pointing out a problem which, if not addressed will derail our good progress.

It is not cherry picking to say that game revealed something significant. I would love to see the forum address it.

[Danjul]

So was Schache a good selection or not?

Schache was a strange selection, in my opinion. He had no defined role and sat on the bench for more than 40% of the game. I certainly would not have selected him. It has only damaged his career.

[Danjul]

Danj...this is the most intelligent forum on Earth. I've been attacked, threatened, called insane names on other forums (reddit and bigfooty) for having for what I believe is an intelligent counter argument.
I really enjoy your counter point but no one comfortably ignores things here. Especially YHF.

I get your Schache angst, and agree it's a bit harsh to expect him to come in against an amazing side and be influential. So wanted another week.
But there are three phases of the game. When you have it, when you don't, and when it's in dispute (loose ball, stoppages). I think Josh is A grade when he has it.

My guess is the other two phases are a massive issue. It's hard to find stats to justify that, but that's what coaches have and see.

l am very happy with your comment, a lot of truth in it.