Always Right Match Committee Round Six v Adelaide on Mars

[azabob]

Is he replacing Wallis? I'm confused (it's not hard).

Garcia and Wallis for OUTS are the same player.

[bornadog]

Is he replacing Wallis? I'm confused (it's not hard).

no. Because 3 in and 3 out plus Wally to be replaced by one of emergencies

[Axe Man]

Is he replacing Wallis? I'm confused (it's not hard).

Wallis was the sub so no. Plus we already have 3 tall forwards (unless Cordy swaps back).

Cordy played the role well last week, Schache has been groomed for defence and has rarely been sighted in the ruck to my knowledge so Cordy forward/ruck and Schache back seems more likely to me. But who knows, Schache probably ends up playing wing!

[Grantysghost]

Wallis was the sub so no. Plus we already have 3 tall forwards (unless Cordy swaps back).

Cordy played the role well last week, Schache has been groomed for defence and has rarely been sighted in the ruck to my knowledge so Cordy forward/ruck and Schache back seems more likely to me. But who knows, probably end up playing wing!

Makes sense axeman. So it definitely will not happen.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

English out is massive.

Hope it's only a week.

[BornInDroopSt'54]

Go Martin!

[ratsmac]

Garcia and Wallis for OUTS are the same player.

Einhorn is Finkle, Finkle is Einhorn!

English is a massive loss

[angelopetraglia]

Any inside word on how bad Timm't hammy is?

[FrediKanoute]

Congrat's to McComb. Would like to see West into the team. Natural replacement for Garcia.

[Swoop]

McComb's form has been strong and he deserves his opportunity. I hope he can grab it with both hands.

I agree that I would like to see West given an opportunity in the coming weeks, I still haven't given up on him

Looking at the ins, I feel like we'll play 3 talls back in Shache, Gardner and O'Brien's. With Hunter going out of the side, I expect Dale, Daniel and Richards to spend some time rotating through the wing and supporting Scott and McNeil.

I also have a feeling that Bont will spend more gametime through the middle to support the loss of English.

Time will tell!

[Mofra]

McComb's form has been strong and he deserves his opportunity. I hope he can grab it with both hands.

I agree that I would like to see West given an opportunity in the coming weeks, I still haven't given up on him

Looking at the ins, I feel like we'll play 3 talls back in Shache, Gardner and O'Brien's. With Hunter going out of the side, I expect Dale, Daniel and Richards to spend some time rotating through the wing and supporting Scott and McNeil.

I also have a feeling that Bont will spend more gametime through the middle to support the loss of English.

Time will tell!

TOB was brought in as that intercepting 3rd so he gets to play the position we chased him for.
TBH if Williams moves onto a wing rotation we're not losing much rebound from defence. Ed has him covered this year and Dale is still Dale.

[Ozza]

I think it is now quite clear, if it wasn't already before, Bevo's view on Rhylee West.
Would be long odds to be on our list next year.

[soupman]

I think it is now quite clear, if it wasn't already before, Bevo's view on Rhylee West.
Would be long odds to be on our list next year.

Then why is he on the list this year?

Hes been one of the better performing VFL players and is surely being groomed for at least one of the two small outside roles we just copped injuries in. If he isn't getting a call up now when will he?

I don't rate him but I am very annoyed when the club also doesn't rate him but keeps him on the list.

[azabob]

Game 200 for Stef Martin this week.

[bornadog]

Then why is he on the list this year?

Hes been one of the better performing VFL players and is surely being groomed for at least one of the two small outside roles we just copped injuries in. If he isn't getting a call up now when will he?

I don't rate him but I am very annoyed when the club also doesn't rate him but keeps him on the list.

Young players are kept on the list as there is a chance they will develop and become a good player. Some players take longer to develop, especially talls. Tim English is a good example, some woofers wanted to trade him not that long ago.

Liam Picken started at Collingwood as an 18 year old but they didn't think he would make it, and eventually in his early 20s we rookied him.

I agree we keep some players a bit too long, but you need your backups and soldiers as well.

As for West, I can't see he will make it, but you never know.