Always Right Match Committee Round Nine v Collingwood at Marvel

[jeemak]

Nah hes a show pony Jeemak told me so.

It's like he wants him out or something.

Replace Brian with Jeemak:

[SquirrelGrip]

With Cody and VDM out for a significant period (plus Garcia), who becomes our small pressure forward? West surely at least throws himself at the ball. Maybe Arthur for his pace? Does Caleb move forward?

[Bulldog4life]

Replace Brian with Jeemak:

Poor Brian and wife were killed in the bush fires in 2009.

[Go_Dogs]

Out:
Cody Weightman (Collar Bone)
Ryan Gardner (Ankle)
Tim O'Brian (Calf)
VDM (Hammy)
Josh Dunkley (Concussion)
Martin

In:
Bont
Keath
English
Wallis
JUH
Schache

Looks about right to me, subject to seeing how injuries turn out.

[Scraggers]

With Cody and VDM out for a significant period (plus Garcia), who becomes our small pressure forward? West surely at least throws himself at the ball. Maybe Arthur for his pace? Does Caleb move forward?

I would like to see Arthur replace Weightman. I think it’s a good swap. I love Arthur’s energy.

[DOG GOD]

I would like to see Arthur replace Weightman. I think it’s a good swap. I love Arthur’s energy.

With Weightman gone, we need a fwd who can chase, chase hard and has pace. Arthur it is. No one else on our list comes under this equation.

[Grantysghost]

Poor Brian and wife were killed in the bush fires in 2009.

Are you replacing jeemak in that sense?

(disclaimer very tragic).

[Grantysghost]

With Weightman gone, we need a fwd who can chase, chase hard and has pace. Arthur it is. No one else on our list comes under this equation.

West? Arthur is too raw yet for mine.

[GVGjr]

West? Arthur is too raw yet for mine.

West should be considered before Arthur but we might be desperate for a good news story.

[Grantysghost]

West should be considered before Arthur but we might be desperate for a good news story.

I won't be cynical, but it is Sir Doug Nicholls round.

It would be an awesome story for sure but West has to be rewarded.

[DOG GOD]

West? Arthur is too raw yet for mine.

West doesn’t have pace does he ? If we don’t get pace in there, the ball will come out with absolute ease.
I’m not sure what the answer is. If West was to be considered, then surely it would’ve been before the selection of McComb.
We need a small crumbing fwd with pace and even though Arthur is raw, maybe it’s just that we need.

[Grantysghost]

West doesn’t have pace does he ? If we don’t get pace in there, the ball will come out with absolute ease.
I’m not sure what the answer is. If West was to be considered, then surely it would’ve been before the selection of McComb.
We need a small crumbing fwd with pace and even though Arthur is raw, maybe it’s just that we need.

On principle I agree however Jones isn't a small forward he's a winger.
West has a bit of the Clay Smith's about him for me I'd love to see him get a run of games.

[Hotdog60]

West can come in for Weightman and Jones for Vandermeer

[Bullies]

I won't be cynical, but it is Sir Doug Nicholls round.

It would be an awesome story for sure but West has to be rewarded.

Surely West can take the spot of McComb and Arthur for Weightman.

[Grantysghost]

Surely West can take the spot of McComb and Arthur for Weightman.

Do you think McComb will be dropped with all the injuries?