List Management thread (For 2022)

[Danjul]

It felt a lot more secure with the idea Schache would be playing back this year but that seems to be a bust as of round 1 and I have no clue what the plan is for him anymore.

Round one was a bust for much of the team. 44 hitouts to 20 and 10 more scoring shots gave Melbourne a lot of drive.

Schache played well at both ends against Adelaide and got dropped (after the usual 1 game sequence ) and others who were worse stayed in. Schache got 2 goals in the second half when he went to the forward line because it was breaking down. It had only kicked 3 goals in the first half. But In the second half Walker became dominant and the backline couldn’t hold up.

That one point loss was a disgrace and some supporters are still angry.

[Danjul]

No one. Carlton have a few injuries in the backend.
He wasn’t in their best 22 for the first few weeks.

Young had 28 marks in his last 3 games. I think Carlton is probably happy with that.

Especially combined with his 45 disposals.

A superstar compared to what we are seeing.

[jeemak]

Young had 28 marks in his last 3 games. I think Carlton is probably happy with that.

Especially combined with his 45 disposals.

A superstar compared to what we are seeing.

Fairly comparable with Gardner, though is getting more of the footy and has really picked up his disposal efficiency. Not sure how much of it is sharing the footy around in defence prior to launch, as I don't watch enough of Carlton, but it's not something we use Gardner for.

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/...&fid1=S&fid2=S

[Happy Days]

Fairly comparable with Gardner, though is getting more of the footy and has really picked up his disposal efficiency. Not sure how much of it is sharing the footy around in defence prior to launch, as I don't watch enough of Carlton, but it's not something we use Gardner for.

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/...&fid1=S&fid2=S

Young also has a considerably worse one on one defensive winning percentage than Gardner (more losses from less contests), despite playing with Jacob Weitering and therefore on by and large far worse players than Gards has had to without Keath.

He sure can get on the end of that switch kick though.

[jeemak]

Young also has a considerably worse one on one defensive winning percentage than Gardner (more losses from less contests), despite playing with Jacob Weitering and therefore on by and large far worse players than Gards has had to without Keath.

He sure can get on the end of that switch kick though.

I'd be interested in seeing those stats if they're available.

[Happy Days]

I'd be interested in seeing those stats if they're available.

https://www.afl.com.au/stats/leaders...ataType=totals

[GVGjr]

Who's Lewis Young keeping out of the side at Carlton presently?

It will be interesting to see if he holds his spot but losing Jones and Marchbank and McGovern being injured he's been a handy player for them.
With Pittonet out maybe Carlton does a Bevo and let him slide into the relief ruck spot for a period of time.

[GVGjr]

Young had 28 marks in his last 3 games. I think Carlton is probably happy with that.

Especially combined with his 45 disposals.

A superstar compared to what we are seeing.

The Carlton supporters I know are very happy with him. Lets see if he can hold his spot.

[G-Mo77]

Had we actually played Young he may have stayed and we'd have some depth in defence.

With Keath's continuing issues with soft tissue it's a real concern going forward and I'm certainly not comfortable with O'Brien being the one and only back up.

[Danjul]

Young also has a considerably worse one on one defensive winning percentage than Gardner (more losses from less contests), despite playing with Jacob Weitering and therefore on by and large far worse players than Gards has had to without Keath.

He sure can get on the end of that switch kick though.

False. Your stats averages are

contested defence one-on-1 Young 3.2 Gardner 2.4. O’Brien 2.6. Cordy 0.4
loss. Young 1.2 Gardner 0.7. O’Brien 1.2. Cordy 0.3
win. Young 2. Gardner 1.7 O’Brien 1.4 Cordy 0.1

so Young had more of these contests and won more.

So At worst Young seems to be comparable to (Gardner who is impressing everyone with his improvement this year) and O’Brien (who has impressed everyone as a great pick up this year).

Actually, the one who surprised me in those stats was Sweet. He scored very highly in some categories. Thanks for sharing the link.

[Bulldog Joe]

False. Your stats averages are

contested defence one-on-1 Young 3.2 Gardner 2.4. O’Brien 2.6. Cordy 0.4
loss. Young 1.2 Gardner 0.7. O’Brien 1.2. Cordy 0.3
win. Young 2. Gardner 1.7 O’Brien 1.4 Cordy 0.1

so Young had more of these contests and won more.

So At worst Young seems to be comparable to (Gardner who is impressing everyone with his improvement this year) and O’Brien (who has impressed everyone as a great pick up this year).

Actually, the one who surprised me in those stats was Sweet. He scored very highly in some categories. Thanks for sharing the link.

Keep in mind that the Sweet stats can only be for 1 game.

Lets see how he backs it up for as long as the MC decide he can get a game.

[Danjul]

Keep in mind that the Sweet stats can only be for 1 game.

Lets see how he backs it up for as long as the MC decide he can get a game.

Agree.

But from what I have read I thought it was beyond him. That’s why I was surprised.

[jeemak]

False. Your stats averages are

contested defence one-on-1 Young 3.2 Gardner 2.4. O’Brien 2.6. Cordy 0.4
loss. Young 1.2 Gardner 0.7. O’Brien 1.2. Cordy 0.3
win. Young 2. Gardner 1.7 O’Brien 1.4 Cordy 0.1

so Young had more of these contests and won more.

So At worst Young seems to be comparable to (Gardner who is impressing everyone with his improvement this year) and O’Brien (who has impressed everyone as a great pick up this year).

Actually, the one who surprised me in those stats was Sweet. He scored very highly in some categories. Thanks for sharing the link.

Lewis Young has lost 36.8% of defencive contests, Gardner 27.3%. I'm not sure how many each neutralises versus wins. Anyway, that's ~30% more losses for Young.

On average Young loses 1.2 per game, Gardner 0.7 per game. That's ~53% more.

[Grantysghost]

Lewis Young has lost 36.8% of defencive contests, Gardner 27.3%. I'm not sure how many each neutralises versus wins. Anyway, that's ~30% more losses for Young.

On average Young loses 1.2 per game, Gardner 0.7 per game. That's ~53% more.

Now you've gone done it.

[hujsh]

Lewis Young has lost 36.8% of defencive contests, Gardner 27.3%. I'm not sure how many each neutralises versus wins. Anyway, that's ~30% more losses for Young.

On average Young loses 1.2 per game, Gardner 0.7 per game. That's ~53% more.

Keath is 18% for comparison

May and Logue comfortably the best 2 in the league despite bring woefully undersized (sorry BAD nothing nasty meant by it)