-
17-05-2022, 10:17 PM
#121
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
I preferred it when we argued over players height.
These other stats are making my head hurt.
More of an In Bruges guy?
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 2 Likes
-
17-05-2022, 10:20 PM
#122
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
azabob
I preferred it when we argued over players height.
These other stats are making my head hurt.
All you need to know is Lewis Young and Casboult are crap.
Gardner is good.
Sweet jury is out.
-
17-05-2022, 10:21 PM
#123
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Grantysghost
All you need to know is Lewis Young and Casboult are crap.
Gardner is good.
Sweet jury is out.
Granty! I thought there was an embargo on calling Casbault anything until this time next week?!?
More of an In Bruges guy?
-
17-05-2022, 10:36 PM
#124
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
azabob
Granty! I thought there was an embargo on calling Casbault anything until this time next week?!?
Haha.
-
17-05-2022, 10:51 PM
#125
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Danjul
False. Your stats averages are
contested defence one-on-1 Young 3.2 Gardner 2.4. O’Brien 2.6. Cordy 0.4
loss. Young 1.2 Gardner 0.7. O’Brien 1.2. Cordy 0.3
win. Young 2. Gardner 1.7 O’Brien 1.4 Cordy 0.1
so Young had more of these contests and won more.
So At worst Young seems to be comparable to (Gardner who is impressing everyone with his improvement this year) and O’Brien (who has impressed everyone as a great pick up this year).
Actually, the one who surprised me in those stats was Sweet. He scored very highly in some categories. Thanks for sharing the link.
Originally Posted by
jeemak
Lewis Young has lost 36.8% of defencive contests, Gardner 27.3%. I'm not sure how many each neutralises versus wins. Anyway, that's ~30% more losses for Young.
On average Young loses 1.2 per game, Gardner 0.7 per game. That's ~53% more.
Damn you hate to see it.
- I'm a visionary - Only here to confirm my biases -
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 1 Likes
-
18-05-2022, 12:52 AM
#126
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
jeemak
Lewis Young has lost 36.8% of defencive contests, Gardner 27.3%. I'm not sure how many each neutralises versus wins. Anyway, that's ~30% more losses for Young.
On average Young loses 1.2 per game, Gardner 0.7 per game. That's ~53% more.
the original comment said more losses from LESS contests. Young had more contests. He won more contests and he lost more contests.
because percentage is a relative concept it is meaningless without its context. 80% of 30 is the same as 30% of 80.
when you look at the absolute values both Young and Gardner are having good seasons,.
The quality of their opponents I can’t comment on so I will have to accept other assessment there.
The most meaningful stats for the evening are the ones you presented. Where one is slightly ahead in some components of the game the other makes up for it elsewhere.
-
18-05-2022, 01:08 AM
#127
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Grantysghost
All you need to know is Lewis Young and Casboult are crap.
Gardner is good.
Sweet jury is out.
jeemak’s figures
$454,000 |
AFL Fantasy Price |
$381,000 |
58.2 |
AFL Fantasy Score |
46.0 |
$394,700 |
Supercoach Price |
$312,400 |
76.7 |
Supercoach Score |
59.7 |
all 4 say Young is 25% better than Gardner.
What did we get in return from Carlton?
-
18-05-2022, 01:29 AM
#128
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Danjul
jeemak’s figures
$454,000 |
AFL Fantasy Price |
$381,000 |
58.2 |
AFL Fantasy Score |
46.0 |
$394,700 |
Supercoach Price |
$312,400 |
76.7 |
Supercoach Score |
59.7 |
all 4 say Young is 25% better than Gardner.
What did we get in return from Carlton?
Bag of chips id say (pick 52)
We used 52 in a pick swap with North to get points for Darcy.
We got Cleary with 61 which is a different pick im trying to track down. Job for another time.
-
18-05-2022, 06:15 AM
#129
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Danjul
the original comment said more losses from LESS contests. Young had more contests. He won more contests and he lost more contests.
because percentage is a relative concept it is meaningless without its context. 80% of 30 is the same as 30% of 80.
when you look at the absolute values both Young and Gardner are having good seasons,.
The quality of their opponents I can’t comment on so I will have to accept other assessment there.
The most meaningful stats for the evening are the ones you presented. Where one is slightly ahead in some components of the game the other makes up for it elsewhere.
Mate this doesn't cut it and the percentages are what they are.
Nobody's looking for a puppeteer in today's wintry economic climate.
-
Post Thanks / Like - 1 Thanks, 0 Likes
hujsh thanked for this post
-
18-05-2022, 06:16 AM
#130
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Danjul
jeemak’s figures
$454,000 |
AFL Fantasy Price |
$381,000 |
58.2 |
AFL Fantasy Score |
46.0 |
$394,700 |
Supercoach Price |
$312,400 |
76.7 |
Supercoach Score |
59.7 |
all 4 say Young is 25% better than Gardner.
What did we get in return from Carlton?
But the stats that matter (depending on what you think a defender should be doing) suggest he's 30-50% give or take worse than Gardner.
Nobody's looking for a puppeteer in today's wintry economic climate.
-
18-05-2022, 10:10 AM
#131
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Danjul
False.
I knew it, Danjul is Dwight Schrute.
Originally Posted by
Danjul
jeemak’s figures
$454,000 |
AFL Fantasy Price |
$381,000 |
58.2 |
AFL Fantasy Score |
46.0 |
$394,700 |
Supercoach Price |
$312,400 |
76.7 |
Supercoach Score |
59.7 |
all 4 say Young is 25% better than Gardner.
What did we get in return from Carlton?
Are you seriously using supercoach and AFL fantasy scores to argue player A is better than player B?
-
Post Thanks / Like - 1 Thanks, 1 Likes
hujsh thanked for this post
-
18-05-2022, 10:22 AM
#132
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
Danjul
jeemak’s figures
$454,000 |
AFL Fantasy Price |
$381,000 |
58.2 |
AFL Fantasy Score |
46.0 |
$394,700 |
Supercoach Price |
$312,400 |
76.7 |
Supercoach Score |
59.7 |
all 4 say Young is 25% better than Gardner.
What did we get in return from Carlton?
So we're now meant to ignore wing-loss percent but use supercoach points instead? You always throw up stats like number of disposals as though it's the only way to judge a players contribution but when there's an actually meaningful statistic relevant to the position the player plays like how often they lose a one-on-one contest it needs "relevant context"? Surely you can just recognize that in this particular area Gardner is out-performing Young?
-
18-05-2022, 10:41 AM
#133
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
hujsh
Surely you can just recognize that in this particular area Gardner is out-performing Young?
For me stats that matter with Gardner are Spoils and 1%ers. Gardner is top three for Spoils in AFL and top 5 for Spoils
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
-
18-05-2022, 11:07 AM
#134
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Originally Posted by
jeemak
Mate this doesn't cut it and the percentages are what they are.
My criticism of the original comment was it contained a factual error.
It said more losses from less contests. That’s false.
The original comment used the error to suggest Young is not getting into the game, whereas (if my memory of the table is accurate) his involvement number of 3.2 was almost the highest in the league.
Moving to percentages doesn’t fix it.
The reality is Young had more losses from more contests.
I don’t understand how fixing that simple error before others act on it can generate so much hatred and venom. But if people must then they are free to spit it.
I also clearly said that Gardner is doing better than Young in a number of areas (not just one) so I wasn’t demeaning him as a player . But if you and others insist, I am happy to accept Gardner is much,much,much better than Young.
-
18-05-2022, 11:08 AM
#135
Re: List Managment thread (For 2022)
Melbourne clubs informed as Fremantle defender shuts down contract negotiations
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2022/05/...down-contract/
Griffin Logue has put contract talks on hold at Fremantle as the in-demand defender edges closer to a move away from the club.
Sources at multiple Melbourne-based clubs said they have been informed that Logue has shut down negotiations with the Dockers until the end of the season.
It comes as the key position stopper last night expressed his frustration at a lack of game time under Justin Longmuir this year.
Logue has been dropped twice in the first nine rounds, including the week after receiving coaches votes in a Round 4 win over GWS.
“For myself it is a bit frustrating. I haven’t felt like I’ve wavered too much in terms of my own form and obviously we’re in a really good spot at the moment where we’ve got a lot of depth to build off,” Logue told Channel 9 Perth.
“Unfortunately, people are going to miss out and that’s been me a few times.”
The Dockers stand out in a marketplace crowded with clubs searching for key defenders. Alex Pearce, Heath Chapman, Brennan Cox, Joel Hamling and Logue are all fighting over key position spots.
West Australian Logue said he wanted to stay at Fremantle, but the 24-year-old is also prepared to hear what other clubs have to offer ahead of the trade period.
“I’ll let that sort itself out. For now, it’s a pretty simple focus on playing the best footy I can personally, but more so as a team to see where we can take it,” Logue said last night.
A No.8 pick in the 2016 national draft, Logue played his 50th game in the loss to Gold Coast last weekend
-
Post Thanks / Like - 1 Thanks, 0 Likes
hujsh thanked for this post