Always Right Match Committee Round 22 v GWS Giants at Marvel on Saturday

[Axe Man]

Hmm, I can't see them doing this at this point of the season?

Seriously if they only think Tim in the guts is an issue against whatever the hell GWS throw in there after the season is pretty much cooked, I'd be really bloody surprised.

The alternative is Stef playing mostly forward, relieving English in the ruck. Surely that isn't the plan?

The Stef ruck with English forward model did work early last year when Martin was fit. Not what I was expecting but with Bruce not improving fast enough I don't hate the idea of giving it a go.

[Axe Man]

I'm happy to see Hunter and McLean back in. Hunter can be frustrating but he is our most natural wingman we have. McLean is a good pressure player which is something we have lacked of late.

McLean is out of the 26 altogether.

[G-Mo77]

McLean is out of the 26 altogether.

He was terrible last week. Didn't even get a touch.

[G-Mo77]

Not sure how this in going to work. Martin really can't so much outsidenof playing ruck so I guess Tim plays more as a forward and Stef gets the lionshare in the middle. Wonder if it'll happen that way

[azabob]

Garcia dropped also disappointing.

[Grantysghost]

Garcia dropped also disappointing.

Wonder how close Williams was? He was very ordinary last week.

[josie]

Wonder how close Williams was? He was very ordinary last week.

I thought Cordy was shocking too - always 5 to 10m behind the forward he was on. Always a bullgod but just don’t think he should be in best 22. I know Coburg are struggling but cannot understand why Schache does not get a call up. If he ends up playing well at another club I’ll be an unhappy supporter.

[josie]

Preuss out is a plus. Who will ruck for GWS?

[Grantysghost]

I thought Cordy was shocking too - always 5 to 10m behind the forward he was on. Always a bullgod but just don’t think he should be in best 22. I know Coburg are struggling but cannot understand why Schache does not get a call up. If he ends up playing well at another club I’ll be an unhappy supporter.

It appears he's come to the end of the road with us.

[azabob]

I thought Cordy was shocking too - always 5 to 10m behind the forward he was on. Always a bullgod but just don’t think he should be in best 22. I know Coburg are struggling but cannot understand why Schache does not get a call up. If he ends up playing well at another club I’ll be an unhappy supporter.

I think you are being harsh on Cordy. Fremantle basically waltzed through the our players. A lot of room was also left open for Lobb to lead into.

[ratsmac]

McLean is out of the 26 altogether.

My bad, for some reason I thought I saw him as an in

[GVGjr]

Hmm, I can't see them doing this at this point of the season?

Seriously if they only think Tim in the guts is an issue against whatever the hell GWS throw in there after the season is pretty much cooked, I'd be really bloody surprised.

Alternate view but it's exactly what I expect them to do.

"Tim we still have a chance to play in the finals and we need to freshen you up before that. Steph will played 60% of the game in the ruck and we need to find out if he has the run in him in case you miss a final"

[kruder]

Will we finally see Tim play more forward?

Where to next with Keath? Has he played his last game at the Kennel?

I'm glad hunter is back even if you are going to trade him no point playing him in the VFL. He is definitely best 22.

[GVGjr]

Will we finally see Tim play more forward?

Where to next with Keath? Has he played his last game at the Kennel?

I'm glad hunter is back even if you are going to trade him no point playing him in the VFL. He is definitely best 22.

It's interesting that of all the discussion with the ins and outs Hunter's inclusion isn't making a stronger headline.

[bornadog]

Garcia dropped also disappointing.

It was either Garcia, West or McNeil. I think we needed someone on the wing, so Hunter comes in