Always Right Match Committee Round 23 v Hawthorn at UTas Stadium on Sunday

[GVGjr]

Cleary's kicking reminds me of Shane Biggs, not especially damaging and a bit awkward but mostly very effective.

His biggest strength seems to be his decision making, chooses good options.

Yep, Footy smarts. I think he has a decent future with us but working out his role might be could be a challenge.

[josie]

Neither for mine. More defensive than Dale (even though he is good there) and better disposal than Moz. Not as good a mover I think as Dale nor as elite a defender as Moz.

Maybe like a taller Doc?

Well said & agree-I thought of Doc too.

[BornInDroopSt'54]

We have to own the stadium.

[azabob]

I can feel a sick joke coming on and Cordy will be dropped.

[Jeanette54]

I can feel a sick joke coming on and Cordy will be dropped.

Nooooooooooooo !!!

[Mantis]

I can feel a sick joke coming on and Cordy will be dropped.

Who does he play on from Haw? He wouldn't be nimble enough to go with Gunston would he?

[GVGjr]

Who does he play on from Haw? He wouldn't be nimble enough to go with Gunston would he?

That would be a hard match-up for him.

[azabob]

Who does he play on from Haw? He wouldn't be nimble enough to go with Gunston would he?

Maybe Koschitzke.

As I said earlier in this thread Duyrea needs to come in to play on Bruest.

Gardner or Richards on Gunston?

[bornadog]

Maybe Koschitzke.

As I said earlier in this thread Duyrea needs to come in to play on Bruest.

Gardner or Richards on Gunston?

Not Richards.

[GVGjr]

Maybe Koschitzke.

As I said earlier in this thread Duyrea needs to come in to play on Bruest.

Gardner or Richards on Gunston?

Breust and Moore might be a handful for us.

Gardner on Gunston, Cordy on Kosi and I can't find a match-up for Darcy unless it's Darcy on Kosi.
Impey, O'Meara, Breust and Moore were the other forwards last week.
Would O'Brien or a fit Khamis be a better option than Darcy for this round?

Matching up on the smaller forwards could be a challenge for us.

[bornadog]

Breust and Moore might be a handful for us.

Gardner on Gunston, Cordy on Kosi and I can't find a match-up for Darcy unless it's Darcy on Kosi.
Impey, O'Meara, Breust and Moore were the other forwards last week.
Would O'Brien or a fit Khamis be a better option than Darcy for this round?

Matching up on the smaller forwards could be a challenge for us.

Drop Martin and move Darcy to Fwd/Ruck and bring in either TOB or Buku for the backline.

[Axe Man]

Drop Martin and move Darcy to Fwd/Ruck and bring in either TOB or Buku for the backline.

Why on earth would we throw Darcy into a role he hasn't been playing at any level in recent times in such an important game?

[Bulldog Joe]

Why on earth would we throw Darcy into a role he hasn't been playing at any level in recent times in such an important game?

I am certainly not opposed to it. He has done it at VFL very effectively, just not since Martin has been back playing.

Could we play him as second ruck but with a backline role when not in the ruck.

He could take the resting ruckman when in the backline. A bit of time on McEvoy might be good for the experience.

[bornadog]

I am certainly not opposed to it. He has done it at VFL very effectively, just not since Martin has been back playing.

Could we play him as second ruck but with a backline role when not in the ruck.

He could take the resting ruckman when in the backline. A bit of time on McEvoy might be good for the experience.

Yes, good alternative

[GVGjr]

I am certainly not opposed to it. He has done it at VFL very effectively, just not since Martin has been back playing.

Could we play him as second ruck but with a backline role when not in the ruck.

He could take the resting ruckman when in the backline. A bit of time on McEvoy might be good for the experience.

Without Lewis, the Hawks went in with just two taller forwards last week, Kosi and Gunston.
Do you think he would be a decent option for Kosi?

If Martin gets dropped I think Bruce will be his replacement.