Trade hypotheticals

[Grantysghost]

Feels like we have sent a lot more players the Saints way than vice versa over the years.

What about Bruce Duperouzel!

[bornadog]

What about Bruce Duperouzel!

Is he the only one we ever got from the Saints?

[azabob]

Is he the only one we ever got from the Saints?

Nicky Winnmar

[GVGjr]

Josh Bruce

[Grantysghost]

Is he the only one we ever got from the Saints?

Winmar.

[bornadog]

Nicky Winnmar

Josh Bruce

How can I forget

[Grantysghost]

Barry Hall (kind of)

[azabob]

Gee a few have gone the other way; Beveridge, Powell, Penny, Ray, Stevens and I'm sure there is more.

[soupman]

Gee a few have gone the other way; Beveridge, Powell, Penny, Ray, Stevens and I'm sure there is more.

Tom Campbell is there now. Shane Birss is another.

[Mantis]

Is he the only one we ever got from the Saints?

Dean Chiron... played 1 (amazing) game for us and was then shipped off to Melbourne.

[bornadog]

Dean Chiron... played 1 (amazing) game for us and was then shipped off to Melbourne.

Can't even remember him

[jeemak]

Young played in the forward pocket and the ball rarely entered the forward line. Bruce was CHF and Naughton FF. The dogs kicked 1 goal in the second half, making a total of 5 for the game.

Grundy played close to a career best performance, destroying English. As the AFL website reports:

Brodie Grundy started 2020 as he ended 2019 with an outstanding performance to set up Collingwood's win tonight. 37 hitouts, including 12 to-advantage, a game-high nine score involvements from 19 disposals is a great way to start the new season.

Young was irrelevant. But dropped for the season? (Naughton had 2 disposals)

You're aware that after round one the players had to train away from the club and the view from our official arbiter of acceptable playing weights and heights was Young came back well and truly out of condition/ unfit to play, right?

The way you've typed it makes it seem as if round one happened, and then round two and the rest of the season happened immediately afterwards when the reality is there was a two and a half month break between rounds one and two!

[Grantysghost]

You're aware that after round one the players had to train away from the club and the view from our official arbiter of acceptable playing weights and heights was Young came back well and truly out of condition/ unfit to play, right?

The way you've typed it makes it seem as if round one happened, and then round two and the rest of the season happened immediately afterwards when the reality is there was a two and a half month break between rounds one and two!

And many many many pies.

[azabob]

You're aware that after round one the players had to train away from the club and the view from our official arbiter of acceptable playing weights and heights was Young came back well and truly out of condition/ unfit to play, right?

The way you've typed it makes it seem as if round one happened, and then round two and the rest of the season happened immediately afterwards when the reality is there was a two and a half month break between rounds one and two!

BAD finds a way, he always, finds a way... except in maybe this instance.

[bornadog]

BAD finds a way, he always, finds a way... except in maybe this instance.

actually had Inside info on that one