Club to Conduct Review

[bornadog]

According to Channel Seven:

The Bulldogs will conduct a thorough review as pressure mounts on coach Luke Beveridge. He says his players lost concentration during a costly elimination final fade-out against the Dockers.

After two years of shortened pre-seasons due to COVID, the elimination exit will allow the Dogs to undertake a more thorough review of their football program compared to recent campaigns.

[jeemak]

The media are smelling blood, get ready for a massive massive offer from EFC for Bevo to coach there. I'm not worried about it actually coming to fruition, mind, just think that's the path things will take.

It's good we're undertaking a review, hopefully it produces something we can act upon.

[FrediKanoute]

The media are smelling blood, get ready for a massive massive offer from EFC for Bevo to coach there. I'm not worried about it actually coming to fruition, mind, just think that's the path things will take.

It's good we're undertaking a review, hopefully it produces something we can act upon.

Agree, but so long as its a proper review and not a witch hunt or a gloss over to keep the supporters happy.

We have some bits and pieces that are not working, but 75% is working so the review really should be how do we bridge that last gap and focus not on Bevo specificallly, but on:

1) List deficiencies
2) Coaching deficiencies
3) Selection policies
4) Gameplan and Tactics - Plan's B, C etc

Not sure there is a lot wrong and mostly they ok. It should be a positive review rather than a bloodletting. Sadly review's tend to end up as bloodletting because the media want someone to blame.

[jeemak]

Agree, but so long as its a proper review and not a witch hunt or a gloss over to keep the supporters happy.

We have some bits and pieces that are not working, but 75% is working so the review really should be how do we bridge that last gap and focus not on Bevo specificallly, but on:

1) List deficiencies
2) Coaching deficiencies
3) Selection policies
4) Gameplan and Tactics - Plan's B, C etc

Not sure there is a lot wrong and mostly they ok. It should be a positive review rather than a bloodletting. Sadly review's tend to end up as bloodletting because the media want someone to blame.

It'll be interesting to see how we execute it versus how the noise/ reporting/ supporter wishes expect us to.

If I strip it back what I'm seeing is a club that feels it hasn't been able to really enact thorough process the past two years and now has the clear air to do so. Tick. Two years in hubs going into lockdown versus no hubs and no return to lock down should provide us with sufficient access to everyone we need to have access to when we need it.

We all concentrate on the grand final loss as being a mentally draining event on our players, however, the physical and emotional toll of hubbing to the death after an already exhausting season isn't ever talked about and it should be.

Send me interstate for work for five days and I want to get my stab on.....do it for five weeks without any freedom plus the pressure of winning finals and participating in a grand final and I'm probably searching the dark web for inspiration on how to do all sorts of things.......(I've thought of the things, so you don't have to......and no, I'm not posting those thoughts).

So what would I want to see?

- How do we optimise our soft cap spend
- What support do the players need to enact on-field leadership/ empowerment in alignment with instruction/ the plan
- List assessment/ actions
- General best practice house keeping and process

There's no time for in depth game strategy and tactical reviews, and in honesty, too much in one hit will just get noses out of joint.

[azabob]

It'll be interesting to see how we execute it versus how the noise/ reporting/ supporter wishes expect us to.

If I strip it back what I'm seeing is a club that feels it hasn't been able to really enact thorough process the past two years and now has the clear air to do so. Tick. Two years in hubs going into lockdown versus no hubs and no return to lock down should provide us with sufficient access to everyone we need to have access to when we need it.

We all concentrate on the grand final loss as being a mentally draining event on our players, however, the physical and emotional toll of hubbing to the death after an already exhausting season isn't ever talked about and it should be.

Send me interstate for work for five days and I want to get my stab on.....do it for five weeks without any freedom plus the pressure of winning finals and participating in a grand final and I'm probably searching the dark web for inspiration on how to do all sorts of things.......(I've thought of the things, so you don't have to......and no, I'm not posting those thoughts).

So what would I want to see?

- How do we optimise our soft cap spend
- What support do the players need to enact on-field leadership/ empowerment in alignment with instruction/ the plan
- List assessment/ actions
- General best practice house keeping and process

There's no time for in depth game strategy and tactical reviews, and in honesty, too much in one hit will just get noses out of joint.

Jee surely we need to also review the strategy and tactics? The players either don't believe in the game plan or don't understand it.

The same issues week after week were on show for all to see.

For mine it would be borderline irrational not to strip the game plan / strategy / tactics back and then build it back up.

If we don't chances 2023 will be worse.

[bornadog]

For mine it would border on negligence not to strip the game plan / strategy / tactics back and then build it back up.

But that is for the coaches to do, not some other party.

The review needs to work out if the coaches are the right people to take us forward

[jeemak]

Jee surely we need to also review the strategy and tactics? The players either don't believe in the game plan or don't understand it.

The same issues week after week were on show for all to see.

For mine it would be borderline irrational not to strip the game plan / strategy / tactics back and then build it back up.

If we don't chances 2023 will be worse.

Who do you get to review strategy and game plan, or match day tactics? Is this person going to be a credible person versus our current coaching group? If the strategy, game plan and match day tactics are found to be in need of major overhaul do you then get a second opinion? What if the second opinion doesn't agree with either our coaching team or the reviewer, do we then audit those findings?

All this while you're putting the noses of the coaching team out of joint and overstepping the remit of the committee/ club management anyway?

If you were to include these areas it would either need to be extremely light of touch or all in because you'd need to be committed and prepared to take on the consequences of the coaching group telling you to get *!*!*!*!ed if they didn't agree with the outcome. And then you're out of luck because you need new coaches.

I would understand ensuring there was adequate governance and integrity in the selection process being in the review, but not much more than that as you start to get into really dangerous territory.

[Mantis]

Agree, but so long as its a proper review and not a witch hunt or a gloss over to keep the supporters happy.

We have some bits and pieces that are not working, but 75% is working so the review really should be how do we bridge that last gap and focus not on Bevo specificallly, but on:

1) List deficiencies
2) Coaching deficiencies
3) Selection policies
4) Gameplan and Tactics - Plan's B, C etc

Not sure there is a lot wrong and mostly they ok. It should be a positive review rather than a bloodletting. Sadly review's tend to end up as bloodletting because the media want someone to blame.

There also needs to be a review of our physical conditioning/ player rehab dept.

We have way too many soft tissue injuries... but they all pretty much all happen at training... why is that? I can think of 4 which happened at key times:

* O'Brien - did a calf in the pre-season which pretty much rail-roaded his season. Started in the VFL and never got going. Given he had an extra 6-8 weeks holiday as Hawthorn's season finished much earlier than ours was his training load impacted? We brought him in for a specific purpose and got nothing out of him at all.

* Keath - hamstring injury at training, never got going afterwards. How did this happen?

* English - did a hamstring at training when coming back from concussion. How did this happen?

* Libba - did a hamstring at training prior to the EF. How the *!*!*!*! did this happen? How good would have he been in greasy conditions on Saturday night.

[bornadog]

There also needs to be a review of our physical conditioning/ player rehab dept.

We have way too many soft tissue injuries... but they all pretty much all happen at training... why is that? I can think of 4 which happened at key times:

* O'Brien - did a calf in the pre-season which pretty much rail-roaded his season. Started in the VFL and never got going. Given he had an extra 6-8 weeks holiday as Hawthorn's season finished much earlier than ours was his training load impacted? We brought him in for a specific purpose and got nothing out of him at all.

* Keath - hamstring injury at training, never got going afterwards. How did this happen?

* English - did a hamstring at training when coming back from concussion. How did this happen?

* Libba - did a hamstring at training prior to the EF. How the *!*!*!*! did this happen? How good would have he been in greasy conditions on Saturday night.

Is this any different to other clubs? Genuine question, because I don't know and it would be good to compare and give a tick to conditioning.

Needs a review, that is for sure.

[azabob]

There also needs to be a review of our physical conditioning/ player rehab dept.

We have way too many soft tissue injuries... but they all pretty much all happen at training... why is that? I can think of 4 which happened at key times:

* O'Brien - did a calf in the pre-season which pretty much rail-roaded his season. Started in the VFL and never got going. Given he had an extra 6-8 weeks holiday as Hawthorn's season finished much earlier than ours was his training load impacted? We brought him in for a specific purpose and got nothing out of him at all.

* Keath - hamstring injury at training, never got going afterwards. How did this happen?

* English - did a hamstring at training when coming back from concussion. How did this happen?

* Libba - did a hamstring at training prior to the EF. How the *!*!*!*! did this happen? How good would have he been in greasy conditions on Saturday night.

JJ did a calf in the warm up of round 1!!!

I mentioned in another thread it is like we didn't anticipate and train for high intensity speed and pace during the games.

[Scorlibo]

There also needs to be a review of our physical conditioning/ player rehab dept.

We have way too many soft tissue injuries... but they all pretty much all happen at training... why is that? I can think of 4 which happened at key times:

* O'Brien - did a calf in the pre-season which pretty much rail-roaded his season. Started in the VFL and never got going. Given he had an extra 6-8 weeks holiday as Hawthorn's season finished much earlier than ours was his training load impacted? We brought him in for a specific purpose and got nothing out of him at all.

* Keath - hamstring injury at training, never got going afterwards. How did this happen?

* English - did a hamstring at training when coming back from concussion. How did this happen?

* Libba - did a hamstring at training prior to the EF. How the *!*!*!*! did this happen? How good would have he been in greasy conditions on Saturday night.

Fair point... on conditioning generally, in recent games against Fremantle and GWS we applied manic pressure and as a result seemed to get too tired to execute the other way. Our inability to prevent transition and spread across the whole season is also signalling that we could be a lot fitter.

One positive is that we don't have many on the sidelines right now, the majority of the list should get a full pre-season.

[G-Mo77]

There also needs to be a review of our physical conditioning/ player rehab dept.

We have way too many soft tissue injuries... but they all pretty much all happen at training... why is that? I can think of 4 which happened at key times:

* O'Brien - did a calf in the pre-season which pretty much rail-roaded his season. Started in the VFL and never got going. Given he had an extra 6-8 weeks holiday as Hawthorn's season finished much earlier than ours was his training load impacted? We brought him in for a specific purpose and got nothing out of him at all.

* Keath - hamstring injury at training, never got going afterwards. How did this happen?

* English - did a hamstring at training when coming back from concussion. How did this happen?

* Libba - did a hamstring at training prior to the EF. How the *!*!*!*! did this happen? How good would have he been in greasy conditions on Saturday night.

I mentioned this in another thread when the news of Libba broke. As mentioned there was also JJ in the warm ups who got injured. Lot of it is luck, it's just that when you line them up like this it seems it could be an issue with what we're doing or not doing. Our injuries have been crippling for a long time, it wouldn't hurt to clean this area out and bring in some new ideas.

[Happy Days]

The media are smelling blood, get ready for a massive massive offer from EFC for Bevo to coach there. I'm not worried about it actually coming to fruition, mind, just think that's the path things will take.

It's good we're undertaking a review, hopefully it produces something we can act upon.

This would almost be worth it for the mental gymnastics we’d see out of some media members.

[kruder]

The media are smelling blood, get ready for a massive massive offer from EFC for Bevo to coach there. I'm not worried about it actually coming to fruition, mind, just think that's the path things will take.

It's good we're undertaking a review, hopefully it produces something we can act upon.

Stkilda will be after him if we get the wobbles again next year and they continue on their road to no where. Bevo will make an impact where he goes there is no doubt about it.

[G-Mo77]

Good to hear we're not sitting on our hands and have higher expectations than what we have delivered this season. It's been disappointing, very disappointing.