You get to pick....

[Dogs 24/7]

In a very close race it's Braddy Johnson on a wing or up forward.

[Mofra]

Chris Grant, plays CHB or interceptor if we want to go with three talls.
Super football brain, field kicking is outstanding let alone for a big guy.

Left field choice - Minson in his AA year, absolute monster who our mids would love playing with.

[jazzadogs]

As a forum we seem to have identified 3 key holes in our list - elite defender, elite two-way wing, elite small forward.

If it was a defender, I would choose Lake as I remember his impact most strongly.

If it was a wing, I would choose Griffen (BLASPHEMY!! NETS!!).

If it was a small forward, it would be Akermanis.

But the one player from the history of the club I would choose to have in the round 1 team, is a second Bontempelli.

[Topdog]

To fix our current team I'd bring back Scott Wynd

[hujsh]

I get Grant was a great player but is he what THIS team needs?

I doubt he's tall enough for BAD either

[The Doctor]

All nice players nominated but we have too much nice in the current team. Give me Morris or Picken or Easton, Matty Boyd or Foster even Danny Southern. The team needs some steel.

[hujsh]

All nice players nominated but we have too much nice in the current team. Give me Morris or Picken or Easton, Matty Boyd or Foster even Danny Southern. The team needs some steel.

Damn. He would be amazing if set to play on the mid/small forwards

[Dancin' Douggy]

Yeah after a lot of thought I think Chris Grant. CHB. A big solid presence with genuine gravitas and leadership by example.

[Dogs 24/7]

In a team that lacks some leadership and a hard edge I agree with Doc that we need to overlook the star players and bring in a Matt Boyd or Jose Romero. We have enough talented players and we now need some hard arses.

[comrade]

Grant to CHF so we can send Naughton back into defence where he truly belongs

[EasternWest]

In a team that lacks some leadership and a hard edge I agree with Doc that we need to overlook the star players and bring in a Matt Boyd or Jose Romero. We have enough talented players and we now need some hard arses.

Point of order, 292 games, 3 time all Australian, 3 time Sutton medalist, Captain and premiership player Matthew Boyd was a star.

[comrade]

Point of order, 292 games, 3 time all Australian, 3 time Sutton medalist, Captain and premiership player Matthew Boyd was a star.

Yep, you look at that record and he really is one of the most underrated and under appreciated Dogs of all time.

[Dogs 24/7]

Point of order, 292 games, 3 time all Australian, 3 time Sutton medalist, Captain and premiership player Matthew Boyd was a star.

Fair point but I am guilty of taking him for granted but I never did truly regard him as elite.

[bornadog]

What about players from other sides as per the OP?

We are looking at current needs so someone like an Eddy Betts would be handy.

[Mofra]

I get Grant was a great player but is he what THIS team needs?

Grant walks into any team from any club that has ever taken the field. He was that good.