Welcome to the Kennel - Nick Coffield

[Bulldog4life]

https://www.google.com/search?sca_es...n3pLFIea8,st:0

Nick's first game highlights. Impressive. All depends on his body now.

[Uninformed]

https://www.google.com/search?sca_es...n3pLFIea8,st:0

Nick's first game highlights. Impressive. All depends on his body now.

Nice

[bulldogtragic]

Morris:

Carlton: Wants more than a future fourth for Paddy Dow.
St Kilda: Won't part with Pick 56 for Dow + wants Pick 40 from the Dogs for Nick Coffield.
Dogs: Want something back if they are going to part with Pick 40 for Coffield.
Essendon: Involved to help swap draft picks and unlock above trades.

[hujsh]

Morris:

Carlton: Wants more than a future fourth for Paddy Dow.
St Kilda: Won't part with Pick 56 for Dow + wants Pick 40 from the Dogs for Nick Coffield.
Dogs: Want something back if they are going to part with Pick 40 for Coffield.
Essendon: Involved to help swap draft picks and unlock above trades.

Carlton+Dogs seem reasonable. Sains being flogs and presumably Essendon being opportunistic and will gain something (I wish we were too)

[azabob]

Morris:

Carlton: Wants more than a future fourth for Paddy Dow.
St Kilda: Won't part with Pick 56 for Dow + wants Pick 40 from the Dogs for Nick Coffield.
Dogs: Want something back if they are going to part with Pick 40 for Coffield.
Essendon: Involved to help swap draft picks and unlock above trades.

Are the saints serious? Just get the deals done...I said this would happen just before the trade period started.

Dow and Coffield are worth the same - NOTHING.

Saints wanting to pay nothing for Dow and expect us to pay through the nose for Coffield.

[GVGjr]

Are the saints serious? Just get the deals done...I said this would happen just before the trade period started.

Dow and Coffield are worth the same - NOTHING.

Saints wanting to pay nothing for Dow and expect us to pay through the nose for Coffield.

They're trying to get Henry from Fremantle so unless the Coffield pick unlocks that they might hold firm for a while
I think the pick we get for Sweet might help us with the Coffield deal.

[hujsh]

They're trying to get Henry from Fremantle so unless the Coffield pick unlocks that they might hold firm for a while
I think the pick we get for Sweet might help us with the Coffield deal.

That might be dependent on Essendon's deal being done first though

[Happy Days]

If we’re giving up 40 the something back we’re after better be pick 39.

[Testekill]

Pick 40 might be a wasted pick after the Croft bid but I'd rather burn it on points then let the Saints try and take us for a ride for a player who hasn't played an AFL game in two years. Take him in the PSD or with one of our late picks, that's literally what it's for.

[bulldogtragic]

Pick 40 might be a wasted pick after the Croft bid but I'd rather burn it on points then let the Saints try and take us for a ride for a player who hasn't played an AFL game in two years. Take him in the PSD or with one of our late picks, that's literally what it's for.

Yep. At a worst case they have to hand back pick 56, if not another third rounder. It’s actually a trade that can unlock Henry for them this year without cutting into their future picks. This is why I don’t rate SOS. This should’ve been done already with Dow too. You’d think it was Taranto or Dunkley…

Other than that, PSD. No one will touch Coffield without a medical. Then we sell pick 40 for two 3rds and go in with more than enough points for Croft and Lual if he slides.

What is it with list managers being dicks this year more than normal?

[bulldogtragic]

Trade radio Twitter:

"There is a confidence that Nick Coffield and Paddy Dow will find homes by the end of today. There will be a three or four team trade it seems to satisfy all parties. Essendon may be involved with pick exchanges."

[Axe Man]

Pick 40 might be a wasted pick after the Croft bid but I'd rather burn it on points then let the Saints try and take us for a ride for a player who hasn't played an AFL game in two years. Take him in the PSD or with one of our late picks, that's literally what it's for.

Yep. At a worst case they have to hand back pick 56, if not another third rounder. It?s actually a trade that can unlock Henry for them this year without cutting into their future picks. This is why I don?t rate SOS. This should?ve been done already with Dow too. You?d think it was Taranto or Dunkley?

Other than that, PSD. No one will touch Coffield without a medical. Then we sell pick 40 for two 3rds and go in with more than enough points for Croft and Lual if he slides.

What is it with list managers being dicks this year more than normal?

I already asked this but don't think it was answered - can't we just sign him as a delisted free agent from 1 November rather than waiting for the PSD if a trade is not agreed?

[GVGjr]

I get that the Saints would want more but I've now changed my mind that we might have to be prepared to let him go to the PSD. Not ideal but it solves a few challenges

[hujsh]

I already asked this but don't think it was answered - can't we just sign him as a delisted free agent from 1 November rather than waiting for the PSD if a trade is not agreed?

I think if you've been offered a contract you're not 'delisted' and have to enter the draft or PSD. If you don't get drafted maybe then you're a DFA?

[bulldogtragic]

I think if you've been offered a contract you're not 'delisted' and have to enter the draft or PSD. If you don't get drafted maybe then you're a DFA?

Correct. St Kilda would need to delist him. If not, he’s uncontracted and can’t exercise DFA rights.