Rating the 2023 Trade Period

[bulldogtragic]

I will update it as it as it progresses:


Done:

3 x Firsts - for - Pick 5 and 2 x Thirds & F3 (kept)
Harmes for a F3 (ours)
Coffield and net gain of draft points which cancels out the F4 (FREE)
Sweet for Pick 50

Draft Points to cover Croft & Lual


Trades In:

Harmes (F3 tied to Dogs)
Coffield (Effectively free)
Lots of draft points


Trade Out:

Sweet - Pick 50

[G-Mo77]

Fail.

Too early?

[The Underdog]

This could get uglier than a game day thread...

[DOG GOD]

Mega fail, and I think it could even get worse.

[Happy Days]

Ngl I’m pretty heated about all this. These moves don’t make sense in a vacuum, and combined they could be disastrous. That pick we gave away could be pretty decent, and Harmes in 2026 will be a complete albatross.

[hujsh]

Ngl I’m pretty heated about all this. These moves don’t make sense in a vacuum, and combined they could be disastrous. That pick we gave away could be pretty decent, and Harmes in 2026 will be a complete albatross.

I don't understand what has happened to the guy that didn't want to pay more than a second round pick for Bruce and Keath. Why are we giving away a future third for a guy whose club doesn't want him?

Are we going to pay a second for Coffield too?

[bulldogtragic]

So 3 x Firsts for Pick 5, 500 points and Harmes.

That’s bigfooty type trades from GCS & Melbourne.

[Grantysghost]

Fail.

Too early?

Too late.

[bulldogtragic]

Too late.

Inmates are running the asylum. Send help.

[Grantysghost]

So 3 x Firsts for Pick 5, 500 points and Harmes.

That’s bigfooty type trades from GCS & Melbourne.

But but but the rest of the draft sucks, and father sons and academies and compos means pick 10 is pick 34 so it's fine.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

This could be the beginning of the end. Bontempelli will see out his career elsewhere at this rate. He's not going to want to hang around this dumpster fire.

[bulldogtragic]

But but but the rest of the draft sucks, and father sons and academies and compos means pick 10 is pick 34 so it's fine.

At this rate it’s rights to Jaxon Cooney & Levi West for Coffield.

[Mantis]

This could be the beginning of the end. Bontempelli will see out his career elsewhere at this rate. He's not going to want to hang around this dumpster fire.

Do you actually think about what you post or just hit the post button?

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Do you actually think about what you post or just hit the post button?

Eh there's more than a few mumblings about his discontent.

Anyway, I won't bother.

[Mantis]

Eh there's more than a few mumblings about his discontent.

Anyway, I won't bother.

You should bother.... you are free to challenge decisions made by the club but have the ability to stand behind your comments with some facts rather than faceless rumours.