Always Right Match Committee Round 3 vs West Coast Eagles

[whythelongface]

Bailey Williams saved by losing 2 defenders.

.

Definitely. But in saying that I like him in defence. Think that is his best position and where he has played his best footy.

Baker cemented a wing spot today. He was excellent. His biggest issue is consistency. Brings today?s game every week and he is a huge asset

The other wing spot is up for grabs

[bornadog]

Macrae with 47 touches is ready

Does Harmes come back in?

JOD for Coffield.

[Happy Days]

We’ve never, in the entire 141 year history of the club, won a game that we’ve selected Harmes for. Think that speaks for itself as to his inclusion.

[lemmon]

Bailey Williams saved by losing 2 defenders.

JOD has to come in - Macrae in as well? Baker gets elevated into the team, not sub.

Out: Coff & Richards.

I thought Williams was okay. Sacrificed his game to play above his size and help an undermanned defence - I'll take that every day of the week.

In - JOD, Macrae
Out - Coffield, Richards

Happy for Williams to slide into Richard's half back flank and Baker into the 22 for Poulter. Macrae into the midfield mix which probably means Gallagher and Caleb play more on the wing.

[Grantysghost]

We’ve never, in the entire 141 year history of the club, won a game that we’ve selected Harmes for. Think that speaks for itself as to his inclusion.

Lmfao

[EasternWest]

Lmfao

My exact reaction. What a clown.

[DadBod]

Thanks mate, didn't know that. Makes it even better.

[GVGjr]

In's Duryea - O'Donnell - Macrae - Baker
Outs - Richards - Coffield - Poulter - Vandermeer

I was seated right neat the interchange and you certainly gain a different perspective listening to the discussions and seeing the medicos working on the players when they come off.

Our backline wasn't well organised today. For a good 5 minutes or more the bench was wanting Sando to come off and the ball was sort of caught in GC forward flank. As much as they yelled and held up the sign our backline should have barked out to Sanders to work his way too the bench.

This is one of the reasons why I think we need to bring in Duryea to cover the very likely loss of Richards.

JOD to replace Coffield makes a lot of sense. He clears his concussion protocols on Thursday and will no doubt do a full session on Friday to confirm his availability

Poulter didn't make a lot of impact but did push back in the 4th quarter to disrupt GC from getting a goal. Macrae can come in to lighten the workload of our main 4 mids and to ensure we don't run Sanders into the ground after his sterling effort today.

Baker shot the lights out today and deserves to start on the wing and I have some doubts if Vandermeer will be hampered for a week with his knee.

Harmes plays at Footscray for a week.

[Warrnambulldog]

Similar thoughts Gary, except maybe Garcia instead of Duryea. If Williams is set for defense and O?Donnell is in for some height they should be more organized from the get go.

Poulter was quiet. I didn?t like Vandermeer?s fake tough guy act and not backing it up with performance. West stays but on notice, he was good last week but made some shocking errors today, we need him to be consistent.

Macrae, Baker, O?Donnell are obvious ins

[jazzadogs]

JOD comes straight in but Macrae has to slog away in VFL for three weeks?

Williams is 1cm shorter than Coffield. We can go in with the same structure from that point of view, with Jones and Buku as the KPDs. I think JOD has to earn his spot back from Buku.

Can Caleb go back to the Richards rebounding role?

[Grantysghost]

Out : Coff, Richards

In : JOD, Macrae.

Garcia for Laith if he doesn't get up.
Williams back, Macrae wing to inside.

[hujsh]

I know we all want Macrae to play. But it's probably doing him no favors to put him on a wing or flank. If Macrae is in someone needs to move out of the middle since that's where he'll spend most of his time. I want to know who.

[angelopetraglia]

JOD comes straight in but Macrae has to slog away in VFL for three weeks?

Williams is 1cm shorter than Coffield. We can go in with the same structure from that point of view, with Jones and Buku as the KPDs. I think JOD has to earn his spot back from Buku.

Can Caleb go back to the Richards rebounding role?

It is not just the rebounding, it is the intercept marking. Richards is hard for us to replace.

[Grantysghost]

I know we all want Macrae to play. But it's probably doing him no favors to put him on a wing or flank. If Macrae is in someone needs to move out of the middle since that's where he'll spend most of his time. I want to know who.

He has been rotated through wing in the past.

[bornadog]

Out : Coff, Richards

In : JOD, Macrae.

Garcia for Laith if he doesn't get up.
Williams back, Macrae wing to inside.

Who is the sub? Maybe Poulter