Always Right Match Committee Round 7 vs Fremantle Dockers

[westbulldog]

Out VDM Lobb (if Jamarra plays)
In Libba

[Testekill]

If Jamarra is right to play then him for Lobb.


Vandermeer out
Gallagher out


Libba in
Daniel in

[FrediKanoute]

Was VDM injured?

No that is the way he always plays.....

Seriously though you cannot play JUH, Naughts, Lobb and Darcy in the forward line, so if you want to keep all 4 in the side then you drop JOD and play one back (Darcy)

I would drop Vanders....Garcia and West are both superior footballers.

[jeemak]

I'd play Lobb if JUH plays, and give Darcy a spell.

Just feel Lobb's TOG capability and return to form is likely going to have a bigger impact in Perth than what Darcy's limited TOG and inexperience in the west will.

This is probably the one time where a horses for courses approach could be justified as Lobb was pretty effective last night even if he didn't get on the end of one.

[Scorlibo]

I'd play Lobb if JUH plays, and give Darcy a spell.

Just feel Lobb's TOG capability and return to form is likely going to have a bigger impact in Perth than what Darcy's limited TOG and inexperience in the west will.

This is probably the one time where a horses for courses approach could be justified as Lobb was pretty effective last night even if he didn't get on the end of one.

Watched the replay back and Lobb was really quite impressive. Don't see how he can be dropped after that game. Darcy was fairly ineffective until late in the game so I tend to agree that he'd be the one to make way, although I'm not nearly as bullish on Jamarra's season as many seem to be. Reckon he's played two good games and three terrible ones, so wouldn't be opposed to encouraging him to take an extra week personal leave and seeing a bit more exposed form from Lobb and Darcy.

[Grantysghost]

Watched the replay back and Lobb was really quite impressive. Don't see how he can be dropped after that game. Darcy was fairly ineffective until late in the game so I tend to agree that he'd be the one to make way, although I'm not nearly as bullish on Jamarra's season as many seem to be. Reckon he's played two good games and three terrible ones, so wouldn't be opposed to encouraging him to take an extra week personal leave and seeing a bit more exposed form from Lobb and Darcy.

Yes to all that.

Marra has had a few stinkers.

Lobb has to stay was his best game as a forward for us.

[azabob]

The other factor in Lobb’s favour is Sean Darcy is back in for the dockers tonight.

[mighty_west]

Tough one this week and probably should wait until we see what happens in the VFL first but at this stage for me,

Out : VDM, (or Gags if pulled up sore), Darcy (watch the media jump all over this, but we can't play all of Lobb, Darce, Marra, Timmy and Naughts in the same side, and Lobb has more than earn't his spot this week.

In : Libba, Jamarra (if he's ready and if not, Darcy stays in).

[Happy Days]

The other factor in Lobb’s favour is Sean Darcy is back in for the dockers tonight.

Glad to see him back too. Gout is no joke.

[Mofra]

I wonder if Garcia can fill the VDM role?
He might not have the repeat ruining capacity but would make his moments count a bit more.
With VDM out we absolutely have to take a tall out if Marra is back. Darcy gets a rest if so as Lobb was very very good.

It really leaves Caleb out in the cold though.

[Mat Lyons]

In: Liberatore, Ugle-Hagan, Daniel
Out: Nobody (they all deserve a spot), so let's play with three extras.

Those who will be considered to make way: Gallagher, Vandermeer, Lobb/Darcy, Sanders, Bramble, O'Donnell. Much will depend if they want to retain a three-tall defence. One of Lobb or Darcy will need to make way fro 'Marra and one will be painfully unlucky. As for the player making way for Libba, it will be one of the mids in Sanders or Gallagher, and perhaps will depend on whetehr Gags' corkie isn't a deep bleeder. However, if they decide to play a smaller defence, O'Donnell will make way and a shuffle will occuer, pushing Bramble to the Sub role or Caleb being elevated to that spot. Le't hope Calb has a big one today in the VFL to press his claim. I'm sure he will be BOG.

[GVGjr]

Glad to see him back too. Gout is no joke.

I knew a guy that would to say that his wife had diagnosed him with gout.
When pressed why she thought that he replied that I don't know but every time I go into the bedroom she yells Gout, gout gout.

[The Underdog]

I knew a guy that would to say that his wife had diagnosed him with gout.
When pressed why she thought that he replied that I don't know but every time I go into the bedroom she yells Gout, gout gout.

Can we get a “Nets” button? For when someone deserves to be punished.

[Grantysghost]

Can we get a “Nets” button? For when someone deserves to be punished.

[EasternWest]

That's awesome