Always Right Match Committee Round 10 vs GWS Giants

[DadBod]

Am i allowed to say that we have been more unpredicatable out of the middle and moved it more quickly when Libber didn't play against Saints and Tigers? Libber comes straight back in but just saying.

Libba doesn't need to be quick, he gets it to those that are quick. He sole purpose is to get it to those who can explode away. It's a simple role, but insanely important, and one that he almost does better than anyone else playing.

[Grantysghost]

Libba may not play again, just steel yourself.

[DadBod]

Libba may not play again, just steel yourself.

I think people are crazy if they don't get ready for it. A young family, 40 - 50 years still on the planet. That's far more important than the footy.

[Mantis]

Am i allowed to say that we have been more unpredicatable out of the middle and moved it more quickly when Libber didn't play against Saints and Tigers? Libber comes straight back in but just saying.

You could also say that our ability to defend on transition looks better without having all of Libba, Treloar and Bont in the middle.

Ed has a desire to defend which the others really don?t unless it?s in close or they can be bothered pushing themselves.

[Bullies]

You could also say that our ability to defend on transition looks better without having all of Libba, Treloar and Bont in the middle.

Ed has a desire to defend which the others really don?t unless it?s in close or they can be bothered pushing themselves.

Garcia also very big on the defensive side as well when he goes in the middle as is Macrae.

[Rocco Jones]

You could also say that our ability to defend on transition looks better without having all of Libba, Treloar and Bont in the middle.

Ed has a desire to defend which the others really don?t unless it?s in close or they can be bothered pushing themselves.

Ed has a desirbe but also the ability. Idk how much of the same thing they are, becomes such an ingrained habit I guess. Hard to just change via effort short term you have to balance it with winning the ball inside. But yeah he definitely has both the effort and ability but the others have one at most.

Ed makes Adz look better/more valuable. If he replaced Adz, I think he'd also make Libba more effective. The mix of Libba, Bont and Adz like a reverse Moneyball.

[Grantysghost]

Ed has a desirbe but also the ability. Idk how much of the same thing they are, becomes such an ingrained habit I guess. Hard to just change via effort short term you have to balance it with winning the ball inside. But yeah he definitely has both the effort and ability but the others have one at most.

Ed makes Adz look better/more valuable. If he replaced Adz, I think he'd also make Libba more effective. The mix of Libba, Bont and Adz like a reverse Moneyball.

He also let's Bont be the cream more often.

[Rocco Jones]

He also let's Bont be the cream more often.

Yep. He adds value to both Bont and Adz. I believe he'd alsdo with to add value to Libba if he was replacing Adz. Ed is well rounded with speed and defensive attributes, both sorely missing from our CBA rotations and our team in general (any team can do with added speed + defensive nous).

Ed, wherever we play him, is a player who adds to the 'whole being worth more than the sum of it's parts'.

[angelopetraglia]

Listening to Bevo this morning. Sounds like no change to the team. Bevo was confident that VFM will get up.

[Mantis]

Yep. He adds value to both Bont and Adz. I believe he'd alsdo with to add value to Libba if he was replacing Adz. Ed is well rounded with speed and defensive attributes, both sorely missing from our CBA rotations and our team in general (any team can do with added speed + defensive nous).

Ed, wherever we play him, is a player who adds to the 'whole being worth more than the sum of it's parts'.

Except in the forward line, he struggles in that part of the ground and really should never set foot in that area as a start point.

[Mantis]

Garcia also very big on the defensive side as well when he goes in the middle as is Macrae.

Garcia = yes, Macrae = can I geta hell NO!!

[azabob]

Listening to Bevo this morning. Sounds like no change to the team. Bevo was confident that VFM will get up.

I didn't think VDM had been that bad the last few weeks?

[Rocco Jones]

Except in the forward line, he struggles in that part of the ground and really should never set foot in that area as a start point.

I think he could improve forward with some time but yeah he looks lost there and why would we even bother? Even if he was 'good' forward, it's well below benchmark he has set. Ed is awesome down back, looks a jet in CBAs. If we want to add another bow, try him on wing perhaps? Gun CBA + all round small/medium defender is enough for me!

Garcia = yes, Macrae = can I geta hell NO!!

Yeah Macrae is with Adz and Libba in being a limited mid.

[bornadog]

Listening to Bevo this morning. Sounds like no change to the team. Bevo was confident that VFM will get up.

Agree, can't see a change unless VDM doesn't come up after training, but looks like he will be fine.

[westbulldog]

Every time Vandermeer is out is a bonus. imo he is not AFL standard and neither are Khamis and McNeill. Clarke, Freijah, Sanders and Cleary will consign them to VFL.