Jackie Epstein
Herald Sun, September 20, 2009
THE AFL has approved the controversial free kick awarded to Nick Riewoldt at the start of the third quarter of Friday night's preliminary final.
Bulldog Brian Lake was penalised for bumping Riewoldt and it gifted the Saint a goal before the ball was bounced to start the term.
"The view of the umpiring department is that the Lake-Riewoldt free kick was a correct decision," AFL spokesman Patrick Keane said yesterday.
"Brian Lake went specifically off his line to knock Riewoldt to the ground. Play hadn't started. The ball was obviously nowhere near the area and a player can't do that to another player, where he specifically goes and knocks him over.
"All clubs were notified specifically about this version of contact as being prohibited.
"It was late in the home-and-away season that all clubs were written to, so it is viewed as a correct and warranted free kick."
Start of sidebar. Skip to end of sidebar.
End of sidebar. Return to start of sidebar.
Bulldogs coach Rodney Eade said he would seek clarification from umpire department chiefs Rowan Sawers and Jeff Gieschen.
Former Dogs champion Doug Hawkins said it was a disgraceful decision.
"No way, no way," Hawkins said. "I know our game's changed from when I played, but that's not a free kick back in 1920 and it's not a free kick in 2009.
"It pulled the boys up a bit. But when Johnno (Brad Johnson) kicked that first goal of the last quarter I thought we were home. I thought here we go, you beauty, we're into our third Grand Final. It is shattering and we're not there in that last Saturday of September and that's what footy's all about."
Hawk champion Dermott Brereton said the free kick awarded by Shane McInerney wasn't in the spirit of the game.
"If you're an umpire, that is defendable to say it's the right decision," he said yesterday.
"Because it's behind play, it's away from the ball, it had nothing to do with play. Does that make it right in the way we've played the game? I would say no. And if you wanted to take the consistency angle, there was no difference between the contact made by Lake to Riewoldt and (Justin) Koschitzke to Lake straight after."
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/af...-1225777058173